Quote: garry brindley "That's not what you said before though? To carry on your metaphor, maybe Noble wouldn't get us to the top of the creek, but to suggest that he'd take us further down it than Agar already has defies logic.'"
I say it, because although I agree Noble's record speaks for itself, I'm not sure, based purely on what little I know of our clubs inner sanctum, things would run very smoothly between him and those who wield power.
Given that he doesn't strike me as a 'yes' man,and as others have said, our recruitment and retention is crucial for next year, I believe it could cause more problems than it solves.
If on the other hand, he is allowed to stamp his mark, then yes, I would like to see him given a shot at it.