Manu plays virtually every minute of every game and is IMO a better player than ellis,I feel this is a loss for hull not a gain.!!

I've said it previously, but Ellis has and does play at a level far greater than Manu ever has.

Ok theoretically lets say we don't sign Chase but we will of allocated £xxxx (silly money) as his monthly/yearly wages... Where is that going if we stick with Seymour.

AP has promised greatness and I expect he will deliver, I'm not happy saying oh well at least we were in for him and we are better than expected etc.

I'm over the moon with AP, PG etc, I'm happy with the visions and direction of the club, I'm happy with the signings so far, but I as a fan, someone with my own opinions and if I am not happy about something I have every right to write it on this forum, just the same as everyone else including the "AP and PG can not do anything wrong" squad!

In case anyone forgets, we now have TWO quality half-backs. Holdsworth and McGoldrick. Before, we had Horne (Who is never in a million years a halfback) and Seymour who really is out of his depth. We also have Heremaia who has put in some good stints in that position too, Throw Westy in plus Nicklas as a backup and we're actually quite well off for cover!

We can afford a young, green NRL junior as a project, surely, or is everyone still captivated by Dureau, Brough and Chase who will not be at FC for the forseeable?

As Mrs B has stated, Wigan have Green and Matty Smith as halfbacks next year. Hardly a fookin' dream-team pairing, is it!

As good as McGoldrick has been, I don't like the idea of him being a first choice in our halves next year.

Chase is coming.... Simple as...... I'm offering 200/1 he doesn't

It's nailed on so chillout

Great player, I like him a lot but don't expect he'll be first choice in any position next year. (Not at FC anyway)

I hope we keep him, he would give great strength in depth along with Horne, Seymour, Whiting, Pitts, Green, Galea, Lineham, Crooks and Hopefully Aspinwall,

I'm really pleased with the signings so far and trust Gentle and AP to deliver some more. Gutted that Chase deals seems dead but the whole recruitment issues were never going to be fixed in one season. We are a million percent better off than this time last year so we should be happy.

If as expected Johnson, Mcdonell signs and Seymour stays. I think we have a squad capable of finishing in the top 4 (to be honest we weren't far off last year).

FB

Mcdonell
Horne
Shaul

W

Briscoe
Lineham
Crookes

C

Yeaman
Arundel
Crooks

HB

Holdsworth
Seymour
Nicklas

P

O Meley
Lynch
Watts
Green
Bowden
Johnson

BR

Ellis
Galea
Tickle
Westerman
Whiting
Pitts
Kent

H

Houghton
Heremia
Cunningham

28 man squad, would expect one more signing (another young halfback?)

Too many Forwards in my opinion , too light in Centres and FB unless we sign a class FB

At centre we have the three mentioned plus whiting and horne who could play there to a good standard.

2 good FB's and young back up player, looks Ok to me.

Halfback is still our major weakness, that combo really lacks pace.

I would defo 'lose' 1 forward and gain a Centre

When is the Kevin Locke signing being announced? Didn't The Brother say he was in the bag?

You are going to be busy then theres tons about.