Of course he touched it with his hand, Foster was in the process of gathering the ball and the ball was in contact with his hand when Horne knocked it forward.

The decision was correct.

I can't believe you lot are moaning so much with the number of incorrect decisions that went your way, including the forward pass you got away with in the try that won you a point, get over it.

wrong he had lost contact before horne touched it

There was no visible seperation of the ball and Fosters hand,if ther ehad of been then the try would of stood

no it would have been called back for the second knock on by horne..

Hull got the ball back straight away anyway, Shenton was bundled into touch about five seconds after the scrum.

15m further down the pitch

That was the one decision that bothered me, the rest I thought was about right.

we had 9 1st teamers out injured, and we where still bloody unlucky not to win! so stop spitting ya dummies out, god help ya when we put our strongest side out against you.

Like in the two matches last year eh?

9 first teamers, really? I think you are including the youngsters too.

We had four out.

In your team yesterday, you had:
2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11 on the pitch. That's 9 of your starting 13 right there. Then you've got 22 (Foster) who is your number one kicker at the moment so he'd be in there most likely, and 15 (LMS).

9 1st teamers? They do love to exaggerate in St Helens don't they!
My Saints friend tried to tell me we played a team full of teenagers and they only had 25% (yes 25%!) of their 1st team playing. Well, I told him the above and also they only had one teenager.

Saints have a lot of injuries. But mainly to the back up players, not to the starting line up.

the injured list was as follows!
wellens
flannery
price
scott moore
clough
wheeler
dixon
lomax
gaskell

these ARE in the Saints 1st team 17 starters . And yes some are the kids but they are our 1st team line up,

Wheeler, Dixon, Lomax and Gaskell are all back up players. The other 5 I agree. Your first choice halves would be Pryce/Eastmond and so the likes of Wheeler/Lomas/Gaskell would not be first choice.

If all those play in your first 17 which nine would miss out from yesterday?

Only Wellens, Flannery and Pryce are 1st team starters if everyone is fit and available, stop exaggerating the rest are back up players.