Quite - if FC aren't playing well I don't just pop along and support Rovers.

If Asda mess up I go to Tesco.

I think selling Lineham is a big mistake. Club saying he wanted to leave but in that video interview not so long back he said he wanted to stay as long as possible. Top quality wingers are game changers and we cant just keep disgarding them because we think we might have the next big thing. Naughtons using us a stepping stone back to the NRL (ala Rankin) so theres no longevity in that and Lancaster still has a lot to prove And what is £125k - not a bloody lot really for a 22 year old at the top of the scoring charts and ex dream team player

It was 140K

I'd douby Naughton will go back to the NRL (You do realise he is from Bradford don't you?)

Lineham IMO is not a gamebreaker.

People can lie in video interviews.

I would rather he stayed, but if he wants to go, better to get this kind of money and have time to replace him, unlike the Briscoe situation.

Actually, I see Diogenes' point, and my comment was equally aimed at the mentality that fans 'shouldn't' stay away. Fans should be free to do whatever they like, and the club should be held at least equally accountable for fans choosing to do so instead of blaming fans. Equally though, this kind of outcome has to be accepted as a possible consequence.

Exactly, people stop coming and the club have to either sell or make cuts to cover the shortfall.

I imagne most of those saying selling Lineham is a mistake (Seb a couple of comments up, for instance & Ian P elsewhere) are the same ones who've publically turned there back on the club. A little ironic really.

Yet there are posters on here who stated transfer fees are dead, and if it was suggested to them about a player under contract at another club coming here they would throw a fit saying they will never leave their contract.

And before someone asks, transfer fees dont count on cap......

That doesn't make it the fault of those fans, though. Seems to be easier for some to have a pop at fans than question the club about falling gates, though.

Picking out 2 forum posters who do not go to games and also happen to think selling Lineham is a mistake as the yardstick is a bit far fetched.

No you don't go at all and you keep your money or spend it on something else.

I struggle with the idea that a rugby club can serve up tripe year after year and the supporters are just supposed to keep quiet and keep shelling out their hard earned dosh and that any financial problems experienced by a club are the supporters' fault for not backing them.

No other business would expect its customers to keep on buying an inferior product or service.

I didn't say that was the yardstick at all. I think the general yardstick would be "disappointed to see him go, but we've got a decent fee out of it".

I said it was ironic that those most vocal about him leaving and blaming the club are those fans who don't go anymore.

Hull FC are a sports club, not a typical business.

The club have supporters (you say that yourself, twice), not customers. There's a huge difference.


Nobody has ever said fans should "keep quiet". But turning your back on them and still expecting them to operate financially at the same level is ridiculous.

You said



I think it is a good deal personally, however it stops being a good deal if we start shipping out more of our 'better' players.

Read what I said properly.

"most of those saying selling Lineham is a mistake"

Not, "most fans".

Sorry i had Ian etc down as fans. Do people stop being fans if they stop going to games?

Where have I turned my back on the club ???

I have stated next season I will be going back to games I choose to go, when you remember the club left me not able to go in the switch to Fridays. I am simply returning and with different priorities developing within my family things have to change end off.

I have never stated selling Lineham is bad either, its good business when a club comes in and offers money ............

now get a life