Have you got some kind of duel personality disorder?

Why not compare one of the other 3 seasons out of the last 4, to truly back up your argument. We both know why you've not done this.

I know. I have seen a lot of Leeds in recent years as my wife is a Rhino and I was going with her a lot when Hull wasn't playing. I have seen a real mixture from him but when he gets it right he is a real handful.

I'd prefer someone better than both of them and if not then maybe we go with Ogre, Moa, Radford and Dowes with the youngsters providing the 5th prop.

If that's the case we will need to split Moa and Ogre to ensure we don't have Radford/Dowes on at the same time imo.

Wilkes or Bailey? Love me lads let it go!

Bit harsh

Wilkes wasn't in SL in 2007.
In 2008 Wilkes made 26 appearances to Baileys 20, Wilkes made 1 more meter per carry than Bailey but made 16 errors to Baileys 7 and missed 47 tackles to Baileys 17.

In 2009 Wilkes made 26 apps to Baileys 16. Made 1 meter per carry more. Made 13 errors to Baileys 7 but missed 60 tackles to Baileys 22.

In 2010 Wilkes made 27 apps to Baileys 22. Wilkes made just less than a meter per carry more. Made 25 errors to Baileys 10 and missed 67 tackles to Baileys 28.

So far this year Wilkes has played double the amount of games, I'll give you that one. But they're making the same amount of metres. The errors are proportionate but Wilkes has already missed nearly 3 times as many tackles, 31 to 11 respectively.

My thoughts exactly.

Cool. So basically, despite being in about the worst team in the competition, he has without fail, made more metres per carry. Obviously players will miss many more tackles playing in a team like London, where they have to face more tackles, and have their defensive line broken many more times.

As to not bore the rest of the posters, I suggest you PM me if you want to carry this on.

Ah right, so now it's who they play for. Strange then, that i mentioned this back on page 52

And you ignored it.


I don't think i'll bother with the PM, it seems pointless.

anyone heard any more on seymour signing?

James Smailes said on Twitter last night that it should be finalised and announced this week.

James Smailes mentioned on twitter that it should be done this week.

cheers for that.

Don't take it as fact though. After all, Smailes does work for the HDM.

i think i would believe it more if he worked for the beano