Over generous in my opinion. For a start his kicking game is at best average and realistically probably not that good which is a skill that is critical in his position at this level. His running game hasn't exactly had the opposition reeling and his pass quality is reasonable again at best.

If he had high standards in these departments but was simply too young to manage a game then there would be a future for him as he matures. As I pointed out pre-Doncaster game if his skills and 'gifted' attributes were there he should rip it up in the Championship especially with a game manager as good as Cooke alongside him. It's early days for him there yet but the signs aren't particularly good.

Shame it looks odds on it isn't going to happen for Milky and ourselves.
Tim Sheens thought he was capable enough at an early age.
PG thought he was capable of making the transition to bring him half way round the world, and I know Gaz Ellis (who incidentally, has been monumental in a disappointing season) thought he could also cut the mustard for us.

Tbh i thought Milky was thrown in at the deep end last season and hasn't fully recovered. Loss of form and confidence and possibly home sick. Plus everytime he plays he's always targetted and generally gets smacked 2/3 times.

I think he is a good player and could be a quality 7 but not in England.

Hmmmmm

Back in this week perhaps as Rankin won't be playing

What's up with him karlos

Jacob miller is peter gentles god son. Its quite laughable the fact he ended up here as a top earner.

Almost as laughable as having a pub landlord as coach. But I'm prepared (as are most) to give them both a chance.

He was a coach first my love

I still think Miller would make a better hooker

Not til his defence is sorted.

I think defensively it is easier defending centrally than out wide. He would get players mainly running straight at him, rather than when he defends out wide, where he may have to slide across, tackle people who are quicker and running different lines etc.

That's why Thompson has emerged as an attacking prop because he seems to be able to tackle when running straight at him but put him out wide and his tackling is poor.

God no his passing is worse than Houghton's!!!