I'm really pleased for Whiting. To come back from a run of horrendous injuries and play like he is ,takes some doing. My only concern for him is next season as Agar doesn't seem to favour a creative 13 in the side and if Fitz re-signs ,that avenue looks blocked for him. The outside backs need the cash next season for strengthening imo . And with Hall, Calderwood, Whiting and Yeaman all ooc at the end of the season , Maybe 2 of these could be disappointed.
Personally , I'd like him to stay.

for me id like all the outside backs to be resigned with at leaste 1 new addition.

Whiting needs to be signed up and sharpish! We fans can't be the only people who see his worth, so if we don't do the right thing and tie him down then I reckon a lot of super league teams would snap him up without thinking twice! 3 year deal please FC!!

Me too, always does well and rarely plays badly. I thought he was superb today.

Thought he was superb today.

I wouldn't move him to the back row for wire though, we haven't got any wingers! in fact i wouldn't move him till next season.

I think people are doing him a dis-service sating he is a solid player, I think he is better than that.

Has to be kept, seems to be having better luck with injuries, sign him up with the others ASAP, hopfully this will be one positive of Agar signing a contract is that we start to get players signed on.

Whting to replace Fitz at LF long term.

Quote t.m.t.b.f.="t.m.t.b.f."someone dig that thread up from about 3 months ago, it was something about "no place for whiting this year, whiting will miss out, whiting will be in if we have a spate of injuries etc"'" there you go mate viewtopic.php?f=34&t=440767&start=0

Quote t.m.t.b.f.="t.m.t.b.f."someone dig that thread up from about 3 months ago, it was something about "no place for whiting this year, whiting will miss out, whiting will be in if we have a spate of injuries etc"'" there you go mate viewtopic.php?f=34&t=440767&start=0

Thought Whiting was absolutely fantastic yesterday.

Quote wolfie="wolfie"there you go mate viewtopic.php?f=34&t=440767&start=0'" Might be a few red faces re-reading there comments about Rich. OUTSTANDING y'day MOM

Quote wolfie="wolfie"there you go mate viewtopic.php?f=34&t=440767&start=0'" Might be a few red faces re-reading there comments about Rich. OUTSTANDING y'day MOM

The fact he said "no advantage" was puzzling IMO!!!

Whiting is a star. Get hiim signed up now.

I still dont agree with the decision and have seen players put on report in the past without a penalty been given. He could have just allowed us to play the ball and put Newton on report later or cite him after the game. Another example of Silverwood trying to level the game out in Rovers favour.

Exactly Dave. Lots of incidents are brought before the disciplinary without being put on report at all. Having said that if Silverwood applied the law then fair enough. It was such a cowardly challenge it probably even disgusted him - he was near it. The only surprise was we didn't lose the ball on halfway on the first tackle after the penalty and they scored from it.