3 forwards needed regardless, straight into the starting 17, replacements for Paea, Manu and Minichiello. Winger to come in for Talanoa unless Naulago proves able enough.

Pretty much agree Dave, apart from Jack Logan, he’s still young and was unlucky his form/injury and his return came in a side with nowt much to play for, actually not that sure how old he is now.

Agree with most of that Dave but I'd maybe give Green a 1 year deal and same with Logan & 2 years Sanderson if the reserves is a properly organised system next season. Hadley I'd give a 1 or 2 year deal depending how he goes this season as think he adds value to the squad and does a job (but like Green have to look at injury records).

Incredible isn't it. An 18 year old in a poor team losing every week no wonder he struggled at times. Give the kid a chance.

No, not a ridiculous comment, just an opinion, you don't have to agree with it. I was more referencing a 3 year deal rather than whether or not we should keep him. As it is, I see less in him at his age than I did in Jansin Turget.

Like you say its an opinion, personally thought Scott looked the most promising out of the young kids

And my opinion of it is that is it a ricdolus comment, if you to judge a player who was 18 last season in 4/5 games playing in a losing team then it's up to you, I'd perfer to give to give him a bit more time.

He is the current England academy captain who played in the team that beat the Aussies, how many years do you think Wigan or Leeds whold give a player of his potential?

I’d maybe be looking to trim Sanderson , Logan and miloudo and put their wages towards making an effective signing

My reasoning is would we miss them , I don’t think we would

Think they will all end up signing for Doncaster

Logan and Miloudi are better than league 1, I'd expect them to sign for a better side than Doncaster unless they get promoted.

I'd keep Miloudi for another year, but not sure he will stay though, don't think Radford is a big fan.

Now if you' have started your reply with 'I think thats a ridiulous comment' that would be an opinion. But you didn't, so it was a statement of fact.

I stand by what I said but obviously hope that he becomes a world beater.

Yeah I agree wouldn’t be surprised to see them at Doncaster

I think it’s imperative we squeeze every last drop out the cap and do it as effectively as we can, if this means letting a few that don’t or arnt really going to play leave, and combing there wages for a more higher quality signing who does have a serious chance of challenging for a place then I’m all for it

In the second row I think Manu has started a bit slowly but i still think hes got it - id give him another year but id lose Mini and Hadley unless he really improves a lot this year. Washbrook to go too - Two top class second rows to come in from the threes money

Front row - Green needs to come back on fire and stay fit for the whole of this season to warrant a new deal or id cut him. Paea deffo to go along with Thompson. Again two good front rowers to come in from the threes money

I dont get this criticism of Dean Hadley.
Players get injured and Hadley has been a bit unlucky but he is a real workhorse when in the team and like Houghton a tackle machine.
Dont forget he has been moved around and not played in his preferred position in the second row like he did when out on loan at Wakefield.
Just ask Wakey fans what they think of Hadley.They would have him back in a shot

agree if fit he would be in my 17, just needs to keep fit