Exactly. For me it was never so much about his ability as his history of thuggish behaviour. Have to say he's been pretty much exemplary since joining us though, and has gone a long way to modifying my opinion of him on all fronts. The article quoted by StaffsFC helps a great deal as well.

Why shouldn't people disagree with a signing? It's a forum!

McGoldrick, Martin and Aspinwall looked to be shockers but have improved our squad, says alot about some of our other players.

Agree..I was'nt to pleased about the signing and it proves how wrong many of us can be. He has been great for us and i hope he gets at least another year, as i think he has deserved it.

I think he has done a fine job since he signed. I am sure that I recall reading either on this site or the Castleford one, that he played well until he got his contract renewed & then he seemed to ease up [or words on a similar theme.

Based on what I have seen, I would consider offering him a a further contact @ the right price.

isnt that what he is supposed to do ????

Yes... That was my point. He's done it well.

apologies marra, mis read the intent.
I agree I think he added a ton of guile to our game , he will be missed IMO

No worries

That was my feelings too Kosh,I will agree he has done nothing wrong since joining us.