Holmes and wrench are the only 2 missing. Holmes hasn't done much for us so far anyway and Powell wouldn't have picked wrench(even though the kid is a class act)

Did wonder why you signed Holmes and mautitua they are definitely a downgrade

They was ok at cas but nothing special certainly nowhere near the best in their positions

i agree with that
I thought we were decent and strong in defence on our right edge when Lovodua was at 6 and Mitch in the centre

What would it achieve by publically announcing it ?

he needs a kick in the and we should do what rovers have done with some senior players and drop them and play them in the reserves if they are not performing on the field.
Apart from making a few metres out of defence he is liability especially in defence.

If he's been dropped then he'll know that. Saying publicly he's dropped so our fans can get on his back achieves nothing.

Neither have impressed so far. Powell must be behind them coming across from Cas with him, hope he can get better performances out of both of them.

The only person that needs to know that is Griffin, publically slagging players will never go down well. You have to remember he has come back from a serious injury it will take time for him to get confidence in his body again. Being a club who publically hangs there players is not a club many would want to play for.

You seriously think he needs more time to get over his achilles injury?
McIntosh seems to be OK,Cator was all over the pitch until his repeat injury.
Sorry but you are making excuses for him
His continual poor defence and positioning has nothing to do with his past injury

Cheers Brett

McIntosh has had issues with his calf and obviously we all saw what happened to cator it does look like it could be weighing on his mind a bit just doesn't seem as confident in his own ability at the moment. Although a different injury I think, shaul looks the shadow of the player he was pre injury

Im making no excuses, just pointing out that publically slating a player out of form wont help him get his form and confidence back.

I dont see how you think this would help.

Is that what was wrong with him, I thought someone had put cement in his boots.

Send the player out on loan if they've lost confidence, don't put them in our first team.