I quite agree.

Awe cheers guys

If you really are Stilts tell me what colour undies you wear on matchday?

In the second row where he is now.

Ellis on one side, Whiting on the other, we now have two smart players in positions where decision making in defence is crucial. We've been complaining about dumb players for years, these two are not and it shows in our much improved defensive line.

For all his ability Westerman is not a smart player and makes errors in defence that contribute or directly lead to opposition tries. Tickle can be the same to a lesser extent.

always does his job well and seems to be 7 or 8 out of 10 most weeks .

Also got quite a bit of praise on Super League Shoe last night, about time he got some recognition from outside the club.

Super League Shoe? Is that one down from Golden Boot

Terry 'O Connoe also said on Sky All The Trys that the only positions he's not played are Prop & Hooker, or do we know different?

Need a chorus of "Whiting is Superman" at Manchester

As soon as he said it I thought 'he's had a spell at prop, too'.

Whoever invented auto-correct needs shooting

He's played every position at some point, played prop for about ten minutes last year which was his last unplayed position!

For me Whiting offers more in defence than Westy and his backing up is excellent but Westy has a lot more ability on the ball but it's a nice headache for PG to have and then two plus Eliis would be my three second rowers and Pitts at 13. Tickle, Galea and Kent have a lot of work to do but two are going at the end of the season so the first threeare our priority.

Whoever said about "smart players" is hang on the money IMO. Makes a massive difference and Whiting has that in abundance.

Yeah, but how often does he go the length of the pitch?

If I'm right, Whiting missed magic weekend last year. With him on the pitch we might have had the cool head and brains to kill the game off