IMo Horne has been one of our better players this season. We have just used him incorrectly as normal. If he played in the role what he is meant to, he is still a good player. Peope seem too quick to knock Horne, and I know you cannot have sentiment. But I think that people are taking that sentiment and twisting it.
IMO one of our top 5/6 performers this season.

to inconsistent this season in patches hes been pretty good where you could say yeh hes getting back to his best but been very awfull at times, my personal opinon is we should play ellis at 7 and let him play the way he does for leigh with seymour playing of him

Yep, and he's playing with a double hernia too.

I've only seen a few of your games this seen. A few live and a few on Sky. It must be a very dissapointing season for you all. Hopefully, now Agar has gone, you can re-build under new management.

When you played Crusaders a few weeks back, you impressed me. I know Crusaders were poor, but I thought you put on a very good display and similarly at Castleford. Today, I thought you would have put in a good battle, but you were never in the game. I thought Sharp had a good game when he replaced Whiting and I didn't think Turner did too badly either, but apart from that, it was a flat performance. Kicking game was poor and you were constantly turning the ball over. Leeds weren't very good today either, but sadly they didn't need to be.

This is just how I see it. I'm not having a dig at you, as I still thoroughly enjoyed my day and really wanted you to progress to the next round.

I hope next season can be an improvement and will see Hull FC back up there.

Thanks for making us all from Crusaders welcome today

I must have dreamt those times I have seen Sinfield playing at 6,7,9 and 13 then.

Probably his knee then if Dr Agar is diagnosing the injury.
Don't worry about Webb. Leeds have immunity against assaulting opposition players in that corner of the ground. Remember Gary Connolly's swinging stiff arm on Preckie's forehead in the Challenge Cup a few years ago!!!!

i exspect dowes ,washy,hamme,phelps,and obst to be leaving ,with 3 going to waky and one to wigan and webster to be going also ,watch the clear out

Richard Horne super league apps.

2011 - 25
2010 - 13
2009 - 24
2008 - 3
2007 - 26

Maybe it wouldn't have been so high if he'd have refused to play until he got his injury problems sorted, but he'd have been slagged off for that as well.

Radford will probably be 4th or 5th choice prop next season and by the end of it he may be 6th.

I'm not sure what appearances have to do with it? I respect the fact he dragged himself out onto the pitch when he didn't have to, but the point is that Horne isn't good enough anymore, largely due to his ongoing health and injury problems. The club has been more than fair to him and his family in giving him a chance to get back over the last few years but, through no lack of effort, he hasn't managed it. Therefore giving him a two year deal this year was criminal.

From the games and footage I've seen Horne has been one of our better players again this season.

We've got a few better players already signed, not to mention coach, with their ball handling and organising ability I expect Horne to shine.

Radford HAS to go ! has he gone ? have I missed anything ?

Radfords still got another year to run, hopefully Gentle won't play him at 13.

'One of the better players' in another season of huge underachivement isn't much to write home about though is it? Especially when he plays in one of the most important positions on the park. I've no doubt that next year the vast majority of our players will look a hell of a lot better next year due to the reasons you mention, but for Horne to have any chance of 'shining' he'd have to do something he hasn't managed for 5 years and that is remain fully fit.

The most telling question for me when Horne got his new deal was 'who would have signed him if we hadn't?' The answer is undoubtedly nobody that we aspire to be competing with. I do respect him immensely though and hope he proves me wrong.