Potential where though........he is another "steady" player...he wont make a try out of nothing...for me he is a better version of Graham Horne....we havent had a decent right Centre since the panther.

He's not in Barnett's class, but he is still a young player. I'd like to see us keep him and bring in a quality centre for him to learn from.

Try out of nothing your talking world class players normally ! We are not going to get one of them I don't reckon

Hence why he said give him the shirt NEXT season. You really do need to start reading the whole post before picking up on something that is not there.

are you his twin too

IMO It doesnt matter what centre we bring in, our style of play is so 2 dimensional that even if we had a centre like Gidley, Lyons, Cooper etc. we wouldnt utilise them correctly ,they would get the same service we've been giving our centres for years - A late ball 20 yards away from the oppositions try line, with no space out wide. Or a poor flat ball on the 3rd tackle on the half way line.

Im not saying he is in Barnetts class.....just saying that we havent had a decent centre since then.........couldnt understand why we signed him and i dont think he is the type of player to take us forward.

To be fair there are very few who are in barnetts class !!

The issue today is that the whole message board is in shock and so every thread is a bickerfest !!
Yesterday was shocking and thats putting it mildly but we have to move forward now and onwards to Quins.
as RA said last night ,"what point is there even discussing that performance as it was a freakshow from front to back so lets now concentrate on Quins and put it right, in the meantime we will be discussing with a few players this week exactly what playing for Hul FC does actually mean to them "
It was shocking beyond all recognition wasnt it but also remember that the last time we had a battering like that we ended up in a final !!!
We have a whole team almost yet to come back onto the island before the season is up and that experience will show however to start scapegoating at this point in the season will change nothing now but I am sure from what I heard a few players last night kissed their lockers goodbye come the end of the season ..
May I also say that anyone who heard Mrs Hetheringtons comments to one player especially after the match is anything to go by you should never EVER doubt her commitment to the cause . she was as heart broken as we all were!

What did she say or was she heart-broken that passes may go down.

grow up

she said Baldy should grow up too

Seems to be the norm, forget the bad performances but dwell on the good ones

She sowed the seed , She is now reaping the benefit.

Does that mean Agar is Kaff's love child