Edited for accuracy.

Edited for inaccuracy,a good move by you to move the goalposts,far better than pulling them down.

No I haven't.

What's this 'were' lark all about?

Good on Rovers, fully deserved and if I could pick a team to have to face that Leeds back line on a massive pitch it would be them.

Could see records tumble!

A reality check? About what. I simply stated that I wouldn't want Rovers to win and my reasons why based on my own personal experiences. I expect you got a Mickey Mouse Cup if that's what you were playing for. Winning any competition is an achievement in my opinion and I'd be happy if my club had done the same. Hull's progression to SuperLeague was as legitimate as Rovers, who incidentally would have done exactly the same in the circumstances. Although I don't quite see what that has to do with the Challenge Cup. You seem bitter. You should be reveling in your club's achievement. Instead you're reading a Hull FC forum.

Agreed.

I don't get this romantic notion some KR fans have, that whilst we survived through merger, they on the other hand went back to grass roots and 'built' their way back to SL.

When in reality without a benefactor to stand huge losses every year and the occasional gift of a million pounds, they would still be there.

Yes we survive today from a merger that happened 16 years ago, KR survive today due to a fan who is happy to stump up £500K every year and gifts from mad Arab's.

People in glass houses etc.

BOT - thought KR played well, and rightly deserve their place at Wembley, although I thought Wire were poor (compared to how they played against Wigan a couple of games back).

And I also hope Leeds run riot in the final! But have a good day out, that's what the final is all about.

Isn't that what pearsons doing now,a benefactor who is suffering heavy losses yet still gets berated on here by your fans ?

I concur.
It will be a game of accurate kicking and free scoring wingers

I have not commented on the Challenge cup since we went out, I will not break the silence.

My concern is FC and our fortunes in the supers eights, not the lower eights.

By the way I see we have new neighbours under us in the forum, a vast improvement I think and I do so hope they remain there

Is the new merged Academy shirt out yet ? Aren't they playing in Leeds colours ? Could do with getting one in the next week or two.

Fair play to any Hull fans taking this in good grace and wishing Rovers luck in the final. Whilst I'm certain it's 90% bluster and you'll all be cheering Leeds on in the final as if your lives depended on it, I couldn't even pretend for the internet that I wished you luck if it was the other way round. In 05, 08 and 13 I have no qualms about admitting that I was gutted you'd got to the final and became as big a Leeds/Saints/Wigan fan as you'll find come cup final day!

Exactly!! Lets hope it stays at one win out of five visits for you. Come on you Leeeeeds!!!!

Exactly right,when you reached the final I was rooting for wigan,and what you say is spot on,nothing wrong in it at all.
Do fans really think that man city fans cheer for man u,it just dont happen.

Exactly. Been trying to explain that to some southern colleagues today. Apparently I should be pleased as its a Hull team at Wembley. NO I'm not. Arsenal fans don't celebrate Spurs winning. Chelsea fans don't celebrate Arsenal winning. Leyton fans don't celebrate WHU winning and so on.

Apparently as "its only rugby" I should be pleased. Why is it only football that you can have an intense rivalry?




Balls to any feelings of being pleased for the Rovers fans. Balls to any feelings about Rovers deserving it. I didn't want anything other than a Wigan victory in an early round or a Catalans victory or a Wire victory. Whilst I have no love for Leeds at all I certainly will on 29th when they play Rovers.

am glad for my mates who have supported rovers all there lives.i know for a fact there where sum tears shread and I know whats it like when you win a semi,its also good for the city,we have had hull there city now rovers, city of culture ,big boxing nights ,all great news for our great city, Now do I want rovers to win, nah ive got my leeds shirt on now lol

Got it in one for me!

Whilst I'm happy for my KR friends and family, and I'm big enough to admit the better team certainly won on Saturday, I will be supporting the same team as my darling husband on the 29th August...he better not get used to it

the worst pairing for me...the whinos and the dobins, hate them both!!!!
in all seriousness though, congrats to the dirty dobins. enjoy your trip to wemberley (lol) enjoy it as much as you can, as after you get spanked by the whinos, the sights wont be as pretty in the weeks that follow.

(Offy, a whino supporter for 80mins come CC final)

Sums you up then Wilf.

In the major finals that Hull have played in, I have never wanted you to win any but I have always been pleased for my black and white pals and their families that they got to experience it. Jealous too, but pleased for them nonetheless.

3 generations of my family heading down to London for Challenge Cup weekend. Most have never seen us play there. We know we wont win but it wont dampen our excitement or ruin our experience. You would even begrudge us that..

Small minded and bitter Wilf. Sorry.

I dislike rovers as much as anyone but that's the club and their owners, not the every day fans who, despite what they all believe about the oppositions' supporters, are all pretty much the same, coming from the same streets in the same city. I know plenty of rovers fans who were secretly pleased when we won in cardiff

As long as it's only once every 29 years then why begrudge them it?