Know something we dont?...so what will the "new coach" do with Mcdonnell,Arundle,Holdsworth,Miller,Watts,Paea,Azza,Ellis,Pitts,Johnson then as they arent his "own players" either.

Not convinced by Thompson, but if he replaces galea then it isn't too bad.

Still think it is a mistake to release lynch.

Guess we will see in time.

That's a good point people are missing. Rovers' recruitment might currently look better than ours, but their departures also look like much bigger relative losses than ours.

For next year, probably. Could work out for the best in the long-term, though.

Plus they have a habit of buggering off dont they.

Id have offerd Johnson to Wakey for either Amor or Kirmond.

Cas might not have gone for that, though. Would you in their position?

And.....are you happy that Rovers are able to consistently sign better players than Hull FC? I'm not saying we've signed crap year on year but we certainly seem to buy our fair share of cap fillers.

You seem to agree with your response that they have signed better calibre replacements than us this year. Granted that their replacements have mighty big shoes to fill but I've only been impressed with Paea so far. We lose O'meley, Tickle, Briscoe, Lynch and O'meley is the only player with a like for like replacement so far.

Like my earlier post said....so far

I live in hope but the names on the grapevine lead me to believe there needs to be a big improvement in attitude towards every game next season as we ain't gonna have the big names to pull us out of the !

And in turn weve signed better than Hudds, Wigan and Leeds

Consistently?..who,the likes of Mason,Withers,O'hara,2 big puddings of props whose names fail me and could go on...the only signing i would take of Rovers over the years is Dobson...the rest,no ta.

I'd hardly say that calling him 'average' and 'an underwhelming signing' constitutes abuse or 'tearing him down'. Both are perfectly valid opinions.

Personally I couldn't care less who Rovers sign. They are not the benchmark.

And let's not forget our recruitment isn't finished, and also that one if our signings is Rovers best forward.

I wouldn't have minded the Galea they signed, either.

We are losing better than what rovers have signed..in the pack anyway.