Prescott
Best
Barnett Snr
Yeaman
Briscoe
Cooke
Horne
Carvell
Swain
O'Meley
Manu
Kearney
Smith

McMenemy
Whiting
Logan
S. Briscoe

People putting brough in must be basing on him now, as he was average at Hull about from a couple games, improved massively since he left hull. Tony Smith and Horne were much better players for Hull.

Radford would be nowhere near my squad, we have had at least 10 backrow forwards in this time better than him.

Prescott was a great FB, a better alround player than briscoe, mine would be.

Prescott
Raynor
Yeaman
Barnett
Best
Horne
Cooke
Carvell
Swain
O Meley
Manu
Grimaldi
Smith

Logan
Moa
Houghton
Whiting

S Briscoe
T Lineham
B Crooks
K Yeaman
G Raynor
P Cooke
R Horne
C Fitzgibbon
R Swain
G Carvell
S Mcmenemy
D Tickle
J Smith

M O'Meley
W Manu
R Whiting
P King

Crooks & Lineham seriously?

They have made the SL Dream Team in there 1st season so why can they not make peoples chosen teams?

1 S Prescott
2 T Briscoe
3 R Barnett snr
4 C Best
5 G Raynor
6 P Cooke
7 D Brough
8 G Carvell
9 R Swain
10 S Logan
11 S Kearney
12 W Manu
13 J Smith

14 R Whiting
15 C Fitzgibbon
16 S Mcmenemy
17 S Briscoe.

1. Steve Prescott
2. Colin Best
3. Richie Barnett (Snr)
4. Kirk Yeaman
5. Tom Briscoe
6. Paul Cooke
7. Richard Horne
8. Jamie Thackray
9. Lee Jackson
10. Sam Moa
11. Willie Manu
12.Tony Grimaldi
13. Jason Smith

Subs
14. Richard Whiting
15. Richard Swain
16. Gareth Carvell
17. Mark O'Meley

This, but with McMenemy instead of Radford. Honorable mention for Grimaldi (one of the few players that went back to Oz and excelled, class player).

double post.

Exactly the same reasons I left brough and Radders out of my team.

1 Prescott
2 Best
3 Barnett
4 Yeaman
5 Raynor
6 Cooke
7 Horne
8 Carvell
9 Swain
10 King
11 Mcmenemy
12 Manu
13 J Smith

Don't think you can look beyond that taking into account what we saw of them and the impact they had at Hull, positions they mostly played etc, for example Brough played mostly 6 and 9 for Hull, only once or twice at 7, Kearney was a rock but only here a season etc, and a whole host of top players maybe past there best, didn't quite work out for whatever reasons.

Without taking any of those factors into account, based on pure ability alone, what a team this would have been:

1 Horne
2 Blacklock
3 Barnett
4 Best
5 Carney
6 Cooke
7 Long
8 Carvell
9 Swain
10 Moa
11 Kearney
12 Manu
13 Jason Smith

Funny that few have Scott Logan.. I Didn't think he were that good tbh.. Paul King was good on his day but Moa needs mentioning.

Also Horney An Briscoe throughout 2005 an 2006.

I thought Logan offered us massive go forward. A far better player than Greenhill ever was for us, and yet in past topics like this, Greenhill always crops up for some reason, I thought he was dilge!

Prescott
Best
Barnett Snr
Yeaman
Briscoe
Cooke
Horne
Carvell
Swain
O'Meley
Fitz
Kearney
Smith

Motu
Moa
Manu
Logan

i agree 100% about grimaldi as he was a good captain in a vital transitional period for us, and yes went back to OZ and was a star over there.