One of the best players hull have!

Thought Whiting did quite well for his first game back all ways round, but the thing that stood out for me above all else was when the ball went up high to Calderwood, Whiting actually offered him some protection whilst he caught it.

Our so-called international centre on the other side might well take note.

He's clever. We've screamed out for his brains and creativity in the centres. Hope he stays fit 'cos he could well be our saviour.

At 13 for me though

He doesn't stay on his feet long enough to offer protection

Just on the pitch, for me!

Centre at the moment though considering our current back situation.

Indeed. Whiting showed plenty of promise. He'll be back to then bench at best on Monday then.

Hall not playing apparently so guess he will be in the team.

Amen Brother.

so given the situation with our backs at the minute you really want him to play 13? At 13 with agar's tactics he would be wasted.

An extra prop.

Thought he played well and showed intelligence. It's no coincidence that Calderwood had his best game by a mile.

Think I'm one of the few fans that rates the guy. Thought he showed enthusiasm throught today. Great try saving tackle. great kick through for the try and great catch on his own try line. Guy behind was slacking him off for his clearing the line runs but Calderwood will never be a tackle breaking winger and unfortunately at Hull we dont use a winger who has pace and needs space to run into.

Glad to see him back but still don't know what his best position is?

For me too