As far as Melbournes 'Big 3' go Smith and Cronk are far more important to the side than Slater.

I went for Hayne because he is the best individual player in the world.

He'd have a hell of a lot more chance than a new full back

There's no doubting he's good and has moments of freakish ability but he's inconstant at best.

Danny Brough would transform us.

having thought about this i'm going to make a case for cameron smith. most folk have gone for a world class half and i can see the logic in thurston who would also organise the team to some extent. however the best team organiser in world rugby is probably cameron smith who has to direct other pivotal front line players like cronk and slater week in week out. add in his defence, his range of passing and his kicking both in general play and goal kicking and you have a complete player. you don't need world class half backs to win superleague but you need a world class organiser and someone to lift the whole team. that's why i'm going for smith to have the same effect on the team that richard swain did

willie mason

Paul Cooke

Gareth Hock.

He's English, is at the peak of his career, he'll be foaming at the mouth when he makes his first game back, I'd love to see him scattering the opposition forwards whilst wearing black and white irregular hoops.

Oh, and it would mean Wigan wouldn't have him.

I see even the Hull FC Facebook page have copied this question from the OP

sonny bill without doubt best rugby player on the planet both codes

Benji Marshall, or Cameron Smith, easily pleased me

i personally would like us to sign a young aussie stand off/scrum half, it pains me to say but the dobbins have to of the best young players in sl with green and dobson. They come with something to prove rather than a glittering career behind them Colin Best was he last signing we made and look how good he turned out to be plus look at sam moa nobody had heard of him, thats not saying i wouldn,t have signed fitz and o,meley because they have been two of the best overseas players in black and white.

In super league it would be Rangi Chase,

From NRL it would be Todd Carney