Personally i think all of our players were poor last night, the worst thing was that our forwards didnt win the battle like they have been all season. Calderwood had a decent pass or two v Bradford but again last night we started giving him poor ball again. The same story on the left too, maybe showed that Thorman and Horne were too knackered after all the defensive work they'd done to put the attacking work in.

I had the same observation last night. Calderwood has to check everytime he receives the ball and on a number of occasions this year the pass has gone behind him. This is clearly an area of his game he needs to work on.

Or the guy passing the ball needs to learn the skill properly. Horne and Hall have both been guilty of poor passes to Calderwood and every time have put their hands up and apologised for the poor pass. That says to me that they didnt think he had over run it. He plays for the flat pass, we just struggle to make it.

get a life and go on the wire board, better still go try and find some grey matter, its lacking in you, quite evidently.

simple drop him for raynor he might start to play when theres some compititon and i hope he does not get picked over briscoe cause he is the "bigger" name that will just pi$$ me off

no need for the sarcasim mate i was just making my feelings heard it is a fourm after all he a waste of money atm done nothing because he knows we have no one to fill his position get raynor back and briscoe playing as he is might give calderwood a kick up the backside

The problem with Calderwood was last night was evident on several occasions when he ran sideways rather than straight forward, he just did'nt seem to make any progress with ball in hand.
On this evidence you can see why he scored very few trys in his last season at Wigan, very poor imo.

He's scored one try and put in a huge amount of work in defence. Hardly 'done nothing'.

WTF!

is that your thoughts on the matter then ???

Are you guy's who are sticking up for Calderwood the same people who thought Cusack was doing well in the forward line last year DRIVING THE HARD YARDS!!
Open your eye's he does have talent ! He showed that for Wigan at the end of last season but for FC he hasn't done any of that. his helping out of the forwards is rare it's been left to Hall and Briscoe 75% of the time and he always 1 step in front of his centre . He needs a wake up call and fast everyone else has made at least a desent start to the season but him. I'm sure he can improve like i said earlier just like Cusack he's 1000% better this year .