There's a difference between Horney bashing and saying he is not the man for the job if we have top four or trophy aspirations.

Agreed we won't every make top 4 or win a trophy with Rich playing ...... Oh wait a minute !!!!!

Wait a minute what??

That was years ago

In any kind of weather eh !!

Cas, Wakey & KR all had better halfs then us last year but all finished under us in the league we lost some poor games in the league what we really should have won. We got to a major final alright the team never turned up or didn't stick to there plan. But when you look back with our halfs situation our marquee signing injured at the start it wasn't a bad year. I think we will surprise a few. I wasn't keen on Miller but like some say on here let him get a pre season under his belt and see how we go. I would rather have Horney then a over paid DJ strutting around doing nothing.

Yay! Any other argument-losing internet clichés you'd like to trot out?

Oh - and for the record, nobody is claiming that Horne is 'the answer'. Just refuting the nonsense posted about him by a couple of people who clearly have an agenda.

What sort of agenda? I'm intrigued.

The sort that involves an irrational dislike of a player.

Irrational as in "I don't think he's good enough, and hasn't been for 5 years?"

Says the guy whose 'argument' is knitted entirely from fog.

You claimed Horne has never been a halfback. I pointed out that he's played there most of his career, appeared in 2 major finals in that position, and won a trophy. Also picked in the Dream Team once IIRC.

You claimed he'd never been picked for GB there. I and others pointed out your error.

Seems reasonably substantial to me.

None of that means he's a good player. He's not.

Didn't horneys record breaking run of tries come when he was a stand off?

What is he then? hes been at the club for over 14 years. Might be just because hes from hull. You should be proud of what hes done for our club. Bloody locals getting all the jobs! disgusting. Are you for real?