Crookes is a better winger than Will Sharp, that's who he has replaced.

Crookes has not let the side down. He proved on Sunday he can be in the right place are the right time.

He is not perfect, he is not the best winger in the league, or our squad for that matter.

As long as he gives 100%, there should be NO ONE calling him at all.

Neither could Martin Offiah but it never did him any harm.

Should be given a chance if no replacement for Briscoe is forthcoming .

I'm not his biggest fan but I certainly wouldn't want Foster ahead of Crookes. People mention average, then they say they want Foster! How bizarre.
Pace and determination aren't problem with him, apparently he's our fastest player (played against him and he's rapid!)
Biggest concern is probably his height and can easily be out jumped. Although when he does take bombs he jumps and doesn't seem to lend on his feet but on his side/backside.

He needs to be given a chance.

Don't think he's been given enough chances for people to dismiss him so soon . Deserves a chance imho

I think we are all getting ahead of ourselves on Crookes. Lets remember this guy was brought in as a replacement for Will Sharp. An upgrade on what we had and however much I appreciate the jury might be still out on him, I think most people would agree Crookes is a better super league winger than Sharp.

He won't offer us what Briscoe has over the years but we need to remember why we bought Crookes to the club in the first place.

The definition of average. Can't catch,tackle and has no pace.

This

what we saw in him I'll never know, to add to the list of failing's he's had that strapping on his leg all year, so is clearly not even fully fit, and obviously has had his off-field issue too. Woeful signing.

Wow, woeful? Very harsh.

He has pace and bags of effort. And he scores tries.

I think the comment about his downfall is that he didn't come through the academy is very true, if he came from a hull club and through our academy I'd guarantee he'd have much more support than he does now.

Would u say after Sharps rebirth you would rate him less than Crookes!!! Although not a world beater i would have taken a reborn Sharp over Crookes everyday of the week.

He surely can't have fans after tonight.. He's absolutely garbage!! Offers nothing to the team at all... Ill say it again... GARBAGE!!!

In the top 3 players for fc tonight , not that it says much

Was he?? Who's opinion is that??

Whenever he goes near the ball he knocks-on, don't let a hat-trick against Wigan's Kids let you think he's a try machine.