You think Yeaman has been better than Whiting this year?

I agree and like you said it would have to be Whiting.

Yeaman is one of the untouchables, c'mon surely you know that you can't say anything against him..... he's from Hull ya know.

yeaman is , flopped more than a donkeys ding dong after his GB cap

Or maybe it's just that some people think he's a better player than Whiting. I don't think anybody's untouchable but I have an opinion and if both players became available I'd hazard a guess which one would attract the most interest and wouldn't be because he was from Hull.

Yes I do, Whiting has done well but Yeaman has still been the better centre. All they are fairly worthless the stats would also back that up.

I think Yeaman has had a poor season. Flies out of the line way too many times and misses the tackle, Shows little vision in attack and seems almost incapable of putting his winger away. As someone has mentioned earlier, he's a fraction of the player he was when he won his GB cap and at times earlier in the season looked largely disinterested.

Disagree with most of that, Yes he jumps out of the line at times, often as he has been left out on a limb by the rest of the defence. He often makes those tackles though and has also saved plenty of tries. He makes good yardage from his dummy half runs. He seems to be giving Briscoe some decent balls but in fairness Yeaman hardly gets a decent pass which imo is why he does not look as good as he did 2/3 years ago. I don't think he looks disinterested in the slightest.

I don't see Whiting putting Calderwood away that often, he also misses tackle even if he does not jump out of the line.

Yeaman is a better centre even when he is not at his best, put him in Leeds side and people would see a completely different player.

And often not. Our left hand side has been shocking at times this season and he's partly to blame. I'd agree that in the last few games he's been on a hiding to nothing given the compressed nature of our defensive pattern.



I'd say he makes them sometimes, others not. I certainly wouldn't say he makes enough of them stick. When Barnett stepped out of the line like that (who I assume he's trying to emulate), he made it count just about every time.



He makes reasonable yardage, I'd say.



I'd certainly take that point. Lack of service is a big issue for all our three quarters, but I don't think Yeaman has made particularly good use of the ball he does get. Are you denying that he needs to improve his vision/handling to put his winger away?



In recent games, I'd be tempted to agree. Earlier in the season, I thought he looked like he couldn't be d.



Rarely, and usually down to the fact that we're too compressed in the middle and he and Calderwood have been left with a two man overlap to defend. I reckon he puts Calderwood away as many times as can be expected given the service they get. Yeaman has always had a bit of a problem in this area, IMO.



This I disagree with. Yeaman has been a better centre in the past, and could be again in the future. As it happens, he's had a reletively poor couple of seasons and Whiting - particularly when you take into account he's just come back from two serious injuries - has done more or less all that could be expected of him.

Interesting Paul that you think Yeaman has had a decent season while Berrigan has been rubbish, I would say that berrigan has been a better player for Hull this year than Yeaman.

Yeaman needs to step up this season and certainly next (when he will have Long playing with him), he will be on a hugh contract at Hull and hasnt earnt it in the past year and a half,

Yeaman has always had issue with putting his winger away but it's something he has got better at and I think it come with maturity. Senior was always rubbish at it but as his career went on he became much more aware of it and as a result better at it.

Whiting does well at centre but imo if you asked every SL club who they would rather have at centre I reckon they would all pick Yeaman.I would say Whiting has done okay this season but nothing more than that.

I would like us to sign a centre for next season rather than persisting with Whiting/Horne. Providing we get the ball wider earlier then Yeaman will do very well for Hull and will challenge for International honours again.

Yeaman needs to improve I don't deny that, he is not as good as he was 3 years ago. That said he still regularly finishes as one ouf our leading try scorers and is also reliant on service like any centre.

Berrigan to me looks either injured or not interested. His distribution from dummy half is appauling at times and is so slow it's untrue.

Better, but still not great.



If you are reffering to the Yeaman of 3 years ago, I'd very much agree.



He's been very good, I reckon, and without much service.



I'd be happy to see Whiting there next year. He'll also do very well if he's given the ball early enough. He'll never be an international centre because of his lack of pace, but I do reckon that, in a side with a decent attacking structure, he could be a very valuable asset at SL level.



As for the Berrigan thing - he's been miles better than Yeaman this year. And, to turn your argument around, if you asked most SL clubs who they'd rather have in their team out of Yeaman and Berrigan, who do you reckon it'd be?

But then you are comparing a centre with a hooker. The comparison with Yeaman and Whiting was due to them both playing centre? So it would depend if they wanted a hooker or a centre.

I fail to see what Whiting has done that's so great this season, he has done okay but not that much better than Horne who was scoring plenty of tries. You agreed Yeaman has got better at putting his winger away but was still not great. I never said Yeaman was a great centre, but neither is Whiting by a long chalk, he does a job there but is not as good as Yeaman and Yeaman also has the capability of getting much better as he has previously shown.

Either way we disagree so it doesn't matter tbh.

You don't think most (if not all) SL clubs would rather take Berrigan as a centre? Really?



He's been 100% better than Horne. In just about every facet of the game. He's a player you can feel confident is in your side. Horne, much less so.



No, Senior. You said Senior had got better and I agreed that he had, but still wasn't the best at putting his winger away.



Isn't that what the board is for?

They both have areas in which they are better than the other:

Pace: Yeaman
Handling: Whiting
Upper body strength: Yeaman
Defence: Whiting

On balance, an in-form Yeaman would be picked at centre ahead of Whiting. But we haven't seen an in-form Yeaman for a good couple of seasons now.