WOuld not touch Lineham with a bargepole

Agree

I liked him, he had his faults, but was a decent winger, think he would do really well with our centres and halfs.

But can see peoples points about him.

Think we are struggling to recruit new to the cap and lack of quality available, just hope we can pull off a couple of suprised signings to try and replace Ellis and Fonua.

Lineham has gone backwards alarmingly, and wasn't that good when we let him go. I'd take a punt on Tom Briscoe if we were to bring anyone back to Hull.

Fair enough just wondering who we'd replace Fonua with, hopefully we can get another big outside back so we're not losing too much.

Ideally we'd also be looking to sign a line busting back rower similar to BMM or Moors to bring off the bench.

I think Ellis will retire at the end of the year too, so we need to be looking at replacing him (easier said than done). I don't watch too much NRL but lillyman at the warriors is out of contract I think, maybe he is worth a look, former origin player.

I don't want too much :p

I was a Lineham fan but he now seems lazy and doesnt do enough work off the ball like we need.

Keep forgetting about him, would be a good signing strong elusive player with real pace, think he would work well in our side, is he OOC though?

I'd have Briscoe back and obviously Mcgillvary but both are under contract.

Not heard we are even looking for a backrower, all talk is of a winger, I suppose speculation won't come from the club until Ellis announces what he is doing.

Plus last season the club did their recruitment very quietly, nobody even mentioned Connor and Griffin signing.

just have confidence in the staff at FC, they'll get it right, and that's not a phrase you could use too often in the last 10 years

Atkins!!!!! Jesus hes the epitomy of 54ite. Dont rate McGillvary either

Think were pretty much sorted for next year. The younger ones have stepped up - Fash, Matongo & Turgut back up forwards, Logan, Michaels back up backs

Rawsthorne too.

I'd much rather us stick with the above names and use the surplus salary cap (especially if Ellis is retiring) on either extending deals of those already here or aiming for an impact prop/second row.

If we stayed as we are personnel wise for 2018 we'd see the young guys gain a wealth of experience and it would allow us to grow as a club and promote from within. Every off season doesn't have to be about who you sign, I'd like us to use this off season to consolidate and put the faith in the young guns we've got. This will be more relevant and beneficial in the years to come with the new ruling on which players will be able to get visas to come over from the NRL and, as we are in a position to have quality depth across the board in most/all positions in the youth setup, we may as well start the ball rolling now.

tala and mahe get us on the front foot coming away from our line, which current back up winger/centre will give us that when mahe goes?

We need to replace fonua with a similar style of player or we'll be significantly weaker next season

the only other player who gave us what mahe does now was briscoe, but he's another who i feel hasnt been as good since he left us

You mean apart from his CC winners medal, GF winners ring , 5 tries at wembley and the lance todd trophy?

He's been injured quite a bit but coming back into his best form from what I've seen