A lesson to be learnt for most posters,before slating players give them a chance to prove themselves in the black and white.

You're having a laugh,wait for the responses when some of our new signings are announced. Some people never learn,just sit back and laugh at them.

Don't see that happening but do agree with your point

But just watch the reaction to some of the signings we make

Given the comments AP has made and some of the names being banded about now, people will have evry right to question some of the signings, players like McDonnell/Holdsworth aren't exactly top drawer players, the one thing we will be able to say next season is it is totally Gentle's team, and the value of the whole may be greater than the sum of it's parts, we can but hope.

Not every player in every team is top draw though, Arundel isn't a top draw player, but PG sees something in him to warrant a long contract and over the years could become a top draw centre, Gareth Ellis is going to be the biggest transfer in Super League and dare say Rangi Chase will be second

On the rumours thread someone said that they had hear Gentle would have chosen McDonnell over Mckinnon, he must see something in Shannon that we don't.

BUT like you say "we can but hope"

Post of the day there so far Standee!!!
PG has already proved with Aspi and Goldie etc that he knows what he is doing and sees clearly the shape and depth of a team before we do and is clearly a VERY shrewd operator, I am sure there will be a few WTFs going around when some are announced but so far this dude has done ok in my book and we should then go with his rhythm and plan for the future and see how it all pans out next year , I am also sure that PG knows the gaffer doesnt suffer fools so will have thought long and hard with Bomber over who we want and i feel sure we will be a team to recon with next year !!
I think Holdsworth is classy but know little about Mc donnel TBH

On Hulls website out for the season shame doing a good job

Says nothing about playing his last game for us or anything... So maybe there's a contract offer in place...

Would definatley have him as a squad player next season. Done a good job for us and shows a lot of passion. Same goes for Aspy. Shows what players who aren't so called big names can do.

Have to say my opinion on him changed when I read he'd been seen getting noshed off by some blonde in a public place. he can stay forever for me

Don`t need a lesson,didn`t like McGoldrick before he signed for us,stated so.I admit he has done a job for us,but can`t help forming opinions of players.

some people need a head shake. That kid has been a star performer since he got here and am sure his influence, attitude and desire has rubbed off on others. Wouldnt be a bad bench having McGoldrick, Whiting, aspinwall !!!

What a load of tosh we need to get rid of him to compete

Based on what? A series of half decent performances in which he has helped to set up some decent tries?

Not being a full international/MOS/Dally M winner presumably.

Tweeted Ryan asking if he's enjoying life at Hull FC and his reply was 'Was really enjoying it mate'