Leeds have struggled for outside backs all season and he has not been in contention once, says it all tbh.

Broughton is as much as a winger as Hall is yet we bring him and play him there. Hall or Horne are way ahead of Broughton and the fact we are picking him is laughable.

Agree about Hall, although Hall is actually pretty good on the wing imo its just not his bets position.
I don't agree about G.Horne been miles ahead of Broughton as a winger.
Watkins, Gibson and Hall are better than Broughton but the first two would get into a fully fit Hull side in the centre anyway, plus Hall is one of the top try scorers this season anyway. Plus Broughton wouldn't get near a full strength Hull side anyway so I don;t really see why you are using that as your argument

My argument is despite injuries to Tony, Raynor and Briscoe we still have better options on the wing than Broughton in both Hall and Horne. For a start they both have more experience and have been playing and training with our squad all season not to mention they have been playing at SL level all season.

Broughton has been brought in to cover in case we get any more injuries, he should not be playing this week.

Reardon (If not ready then Thorman)
Calderwood
Whiting
Yeaman
G.horne
R.horne
Lee
Dowes
Berrigan
King
Burnett
Tickle
Washbrook

Thackray
Maloney
Houghton
Manu

How have you come to the conclusion that G.Horne is a better winger than Borughton? G.Horne has barely played there himself. When he did againat Saints, he got two trys but he didn't exactly play amazingly. Hall should be at centre if Reardon is back, I feel at the moment we need to play to our strengths and Hall at centre is one of them.
While Broughton himself isn't an experienced winger, on Friday he seemed to have the qualities to do a job for us there for a month. The fact that Leeds have better players to cover injuries than him is irrelevant because Leeds have a better squad

we will be shagged if the half pairing isnt there


Readon (if cleared) Thorman
Calderwood
Whiting
K.Yeaman
G.Horne
R.Horne (if fit) Washy
Thorman / Lee
Dowes
Berrigan
Thackray
Tickle
Radford
Washy

Subs
Cusack
Houghton or Lee
Maloney
Manu

R. Horne
Calderwood
Hall
Yeaman
Reardon
Washbrook
Lee
Dowes
Berrigan
Thackray
Tickle
Burnett
G. Horne

King
Cusack
Manu
Whiting

Well Horne scored two tries despite being out of position and he has already been playing well at centre so continuity is surely a good thing along with experience.

Tell me what Broughton has done to earn a spot in our fist team?

He has Kath's lipstick round the base of his leeds rhinos tattoed peni5

My Team would be,

Reardon
Hall
Whiting
Yeaman
Calderwood
Horne
Thorman
Dowes
Berrigan
Cusack
Burnett
Tickle
Lee

Manu
Thacks
Radford (As a prop)
Washbrook

If Reardon isnt fit, play R Horne at FB, with Washbrook at Stand off andf G Horne onto the bench.

We will have to agree to disagree with Horne as I feel he has generally been poor at centre and despite scoring two tries at Saints felt he wasn't that good there either upon reflection.
Broughton didn't do anything to earn a spot last week on the wing, I guess he just did good in training. I don't think he did anything wrong on Friday that would lead to him getting dropped for Salford though

Typo etc.

Personally I thought he has a shocking game, came up four very poor errors, which if Calderwood had done they would be calls to lynch him.