He also gave some very good ones.

Horney did well again at FB, coming into the line on both sides in attack. If we don't complete the luxury of signing a specialised FB next season, which I would prefer, then Horney would do a solid enough job there for us.

I don't disagree that Horney would do a very good job, however my only fear is his injuries appear to be increasing.

Sloppy with ball at times and struggled a bit against their rush defence but overall we competed and scored 5 tries so not a poor performance but a reasonable one based on where we are and where we're coming from in terms of recent results. I though Horne showed some class touches and Seymour as ever worked his backside off to create stuff - sometimes it came off and sometimes it didn't but the guy is essentially our lone play maker. Good to see Heremaia get some more time and look proficient while he was on. Thought Westerman was once again fairly anonymous and Tickle below par although he was apparently playing with injury. Briscoe had more influence on a game than he's had for a while which was good to see.

Good 2 points after what's gone - we had to cart it out a hell of a lot with Hudds/Brough's tactic of deep kicking but in the end had enough. The last try play was class and for once superbly executed and overall we did enough to deserve it.

Pretty much my thoughts, luckily Giants were just as poor or it could have been another long day.
Standouts for me were Whiting and Heremaiai. Horne played well also. Westerman was anonymous, Tickle was very quiet (although he did take a knock) and Manu took the wrong option way too many times.

Re the Crooks sprinting the width of the pitch to save a try, Seymour just before the PTB had told him to get across once the ball was played and moving that way. Crooks did great with that and fielded the kicks well today, however no real testing kicks from Hudds.

Wasn't at Warrington, but by all accounts we played better then previous weeks. Today we played better still. Gentle said that form isn't just flicked on and off like a light switch, but it builds over weeks of hard work, so let's hope it's the start of a bit of momentum.

Funny out games are viewed differently by different people. I thought Westy did well today and tackled their big blokes very hard in defence. Showed some great passion in the second half. Also thought Brough's kicks were very testing at times, especially his kick offs.

Have to agree thought westerman was good today,still not our best but won in the end. Must say Brough was impresive today with his kicking game and he took our line on very well.Hope he is one of the 6 for next season.

There then, was he?

That's what makes good discussions People see different things in players so have differing opinions on how they played. Re the kicks, I only recall one testing high kick were Hudds were also challenging for the ball and Whiting took that quite comfortably. He did split the defence well at times but nothing that really put us in danger. It was daft mistakes allowing breaks and the ref that were our downfall in defence today.

Apart from his kicking, which was shocking at times

He had a blip earlier this season (possibly partly an injury being carried), but other than that he's been very consistent over his career IMO. The team around him, on the other hand... It's particularly hard for a winger to show how well he's playing in a poor side.

Also, Charnley has only really been playing for 2 years, most of which in one of the best sides about. It's only been the last 18 months that he's really been under the eye as much as well. That's a much shorter timescale in which to stay consistent, with a hell of a lot of supply, so IMO it's been much easier for him to maintain that consistency.

Just a worry going into leeds game is tickle , manu and briscoe might be playing on wednesday night be hard to back up to play against leeds on friday night be 3 games in 6 days