... just don't check his stats for the Warrington game.

Shame they don’t do a “freaky bit of skill” stat

Alot of errors, particularly under the high ball which is unusual for him, but still make a try and looked dangerous in the 2and half.

Need to get him signed up, along with a few others, particularly

Brown, Cator, Griffin and Savelio

Next would be Satae and Sao

Swift probably, big decision on Faraimo as we cant carry an overseas winger out of the 17, such a waste of a quota spot.

Ma'u needs to have a big few games also to get a new deal.

I'd probably keep them all, with the exception of Faraimo and use the quota spot to sign a hooker or another forward

Agree with all of that.

It's tough on Faraimo because as much as I rate him an adequate non quota replacement could be be found in SL. In fact if Vulikijapani is a success another winger may not be needed. Maybe Shaul could even play there as well.

Ma'u is a difficult one. He's an exceptional player but hasn't shown consistently what he can do. He'll also be 33 and I would imagine one of the high earners. Better value may be found elsewhere.

I like the idea of another hooker to compliment Houghton. He's got plenty of miles on the clock but doesn't seem to be slowing down and he rarely gets injured but that can't last forever. Maybe look at a more dynamic hooker similar to Litten but obviously better quality.

Above all the most important thing is to resign all the other names you mentioned.

Are you saying you dont rate Johnstone?

No, I think he's dependable and won't let you down. I was agreeing with Dave K. If we had a quota place available a hooker would be an option. I don't think we should use it on a winger if we decide to let Faraimo go.

How do you see it? Interested to know what others think. Maybe I'm in the minority.

I am not a big fan of Johnstone just think there is something missing in his play,whether he develops his game who knows but see little point adding another 9 to the squad as Danny Houghton still has a couple of years at the top and he seems as fit or fitter than Roby who is still playing now at 35.
I do agree we shouldnt waste a quota space on a winger when we are well served at the moment with the real prospect of Vulcan making an impact once he gets a chance.
If he is released Faraimo should consider himself unlucky as i have him ahead of Fonua on perfomances we have seen

Houghton is the problem, he’s like the Duracell bunny, and he keeps reinventing himself as well, first he’s tackle 52, now he’s tackle 85.

He’s now a half back as well, Captain, and a man of steel. no wonder Jez fexxxd off, One position not needed for change is his, God bless Danny Houghton.

I can't see the club investing in a hooker when we have two and young Hookem in the academy. We will need to replace Mint at some point but this year is too early.

If we do have cap room and even a quota spot available after resigning everyone the I think another forward is a priority. If the NZ Warriors have anyone available with the same quality as Sao and Satae then I wouldn't say no.

And hopefully we can start producing our academy players more consistently, I’ve not seen a lot of these kids yet, but I thought Hookem was a scrum half, think we have a lad from Leeds, Morley who is a nine, As said, I haven’t seen them play recently, apologies if mistaken.

Hookem has played hooker. As has MacNamara thinking about it.

We seem to have a bit of a lost generation with the youngsters. We can blame the CoHA for now but we really need to start bring more through. I get really jealous when I see Saints and Wigan teams and have to Google who their forwards are.

It depends what people want from their hookers these days, if you want a hooker that's tackle all day but at the expense of their attacking play and can also be very ropey with pass selections then Houghtons your man.

If you want a more well rounded hooker with better ball distribution and attacking threat if use Faraimos over seas spot on a hooker. I'd see how Johnstone goes this season first though, I've no doubt if he d come on against Warrington late, we d of won the game.

I agree about Manu Mau too, hasn't hit the heights here , could he draw defenders in and get more offloads out, or run better lines? As someone's said 33 and I think his overseas spot and wage could be used on an upgrade.