would you need a top halfback really though?

look at Dobson, Sammut, Witt, Chase and Holdsworth for example, not exactly household names in Aus, yet there all top players over here, and have all been in demand too.

Who do you suggest that's:
1)Top class
2)Available
3) Willing to come to FC?

Since it's so straightforward, I await your list.

Make your mind up.

Aye, posted the link from the Wakey site a couple of pages ago. [iIf[/i Burnett were to go and [iIf[/i Berro leaves, plus the tiny bit of cap space we still have left now, we should have a considerable amount of money to spend.

Look, as has already been said, Cronk's a current international, no way would he come to Hull early (if at all, ever), and why would his current club release him? Top half backs are like gold dust, especially at this point in the recruitment cycle.

Spot on. There's a reason why people think we get better value for money from O'Meley and Fitzgibbon: it's because their roles don't hinge on the rest of the team, they 'only' need to cart the ball up and hit anything that comes near them. It's at least as much that less is expected of them as it is them offering more. The basic prop's role is the same in any team, the pivotal positions depend on how your team is set up to play.

like i said earlier, do you need a top half back?

im sure Hull would have any of those i listed earlier, and there werent exactly world beaters over there where they? when Rovers first signed Blake green i thought Blake Who??? because he is unheard of, but then i thought the same about those on the list i put up and theyve done very well for there clubs.

At least you admit it, most have been championing the signing without seeing him play and reverting to this 'partnership' with Dobson.

I don't think your point was valid, simple as that. I don't ever think he's looked average for us, he's always looked one of, if not the, most talented player(s) we have. The team just haven't either been good enough or implemented the right tactics to get the best from him.

We didn't see the best of him in 2008 either, he was just still obviously a cut above every other player we had. As he was again until his injury in 2009 IMO. This last season was patchy, but he had off-field issues which probably contributed to that TBF.

Despite plenty of fans criticising and blaming him, if I was in his shoes I personally would be cursing the day I let Hull FC sell me a vision that turned out to be a mirage. I bet he's every bit as disappointed he traded his peak years to finish his days in a dud side as anyone else.

There you go Carl deal with that thoughtfully constructed reply.

Zod your one borning er.