I have been a critic for at least a year, so nothing to do with him joining Rovers from me.

he has the potential, and I hope that the change of scenery allows him to reach it...but there's no point dressing the situation up, he's a liability in defence, and is being kept out of the team by Whiting, a player with little pace who hasn't been playing well on the wing anyway.

3 years ago you could accept his defensive lapses, as the raw talent was there...3 years on and we expect better.

Morgan has proved time and time again that he can bring players on

Which players are these then?
I can think of 3 examples, which makes your statement look stupid!
Cooke went backwards..
Briscoe has had a poorish season so far..
Welham has one of the worst defences in SL..

agree!! briscoe and houghton been fine examples.

How many do you think you'll have this season?

Look - I don't want this descending into a Rovers v FC "who has the best coach" thread. Morgan had the better season last year, so far Agar is on top this year. Nobody has claimed that Morgan is a poor coach, just not quite the mastermind you paint him to be.

Think you will find that Morgs had a better year the one before as well, well according to the table he did.
Dont put Brisc down by saying it was timing as that is unfair, I would love to see your Brisc in our Team, Dobbo is absoloute class and if you could you would have him tom, i also beleive that to be true of Galea and Newton, but i was questioned about the progress of players which i beleive i answered regarding their progress after joining Rovers under Morgs or have i missed something?

That wasn't meant as a pop at Briscoe at all. He played just as well for us as he did for you but was kept out of England by Wellens being the default choice until very recently. Sad to see him lose his place again so soon.

I honestly wouldn't trade Long for Dobson. I've never been a fan of Dobson's, regardless of who he played for. I'd also argue that all three players were already of a pretty good standard when they came to you.

Anyway - none of this is particularly relevant to the thread. You believe that Morgan can realise Hall's potential where others have failed. That's fine. I'm more doubtful that coaching is at the core of Hall's issues. Either way I hope he succeeds wherever he goes - I like watching him and there aren't enough quality English centres IMO.

Thanks for your honesty and lack of blinkers as its sometimes nice to hear an honest opinion.
I feel i made my point and that you made yours and although we will probably but heads till hell freezes over at least we can have a civil and honest debate about it

dobson's c rap

and galea.glad he's agreed a 1 year deal to stop over there.

Dobson is pants!!....can't be d to reply to the rest because it is silly....Morgan is getting found out this year...very average coach
For me Morgan is a fixer he would do for Crusaders what Nobby is presently doing, pulls teams up but as yet Morgan has not proven he can be consistent with a team..AGAIN he is unable to take credit for developing ANY player into a special/international player....Agar=Tom Briscoe

I was gonna try and argue the fact that Dobbos 9 trys this year sit him only 2 behind your Briscoe and only one in front of your next highest try scorer (beleive it or not thats Hall on i was gonna try and then throw in his 60 points from the boot, I wanted to use the fact that he is in the top 3 points scorers not only this year but in the previous 2, i then thought of using his dream team status and one of the favourites for last years man of steel, but then as you put hes CRAP how can i argue that