So what you're saying is then that unless we have our starting 13 on the field to implement our 1 and only tactic we're going to struggle. I think that is evident
I appreciate you're a glass half full fan but your reasoning is flawed as we wouldn't know how we would have fared regardless and 3 of those mentioned are not starting 13.
Even with said players back it would not change our slow ptb, slow sliding defence, inability to break the opposition line and the fact our defensive line is static, giving an easy 10 metres.

All scenerios are ifs buts or maybes I appreciate that but I'm looking rather at our style of play and not making excuses for players missing.
Saints, Wigan players slot in systems don't change.
Us, players missing, system fails.

I'm not an advocate of sacking Radford. I agree that for 2 seasons our performances have not been acceptable, with some massive defeats and a record equalling run of defeats. It doesn't read well.

However, Pearson has listened to Radfords plan, offloaded heavily and replaced with what looks like some great new recruits.
So having been given the baton, Radford has to be given the chance to run with it. The first game showed that this team can play, and yet despite a narrow win against a good Rovers, the few injuries that we've suffered seem to really rock us, which questions our strength in depth I suppose, particularly when key men are out.
The performance against Catalans is the worrying one for me, in that we had the game won with 20mins to go. So Radfords game plan can work and we were good for 60 mins and looked like we'd go on to score more points. The massive issue for me is more about the mental strength of the squad as a whole. Its an absolutely critical factor. Thinking a game is won before it actually is has become a habit at Hull FC. Whereas champion teams in that position squeeze the foot on the throat even harder.

But because teams know we are weak mentally, teams feel they are never beaten with Hull FC. They always feel they can come back at us. We give them that belief because ours is so weak, time after time. Its real and present. Its becoming our trademark.

So, because it is clearly a collective problem the responsibility ultimately is Radfords to eradicate this softness that is part of our team make-up. If he can instil a mental strength, where the team think and behave as one, often lead by a captains inspiration and his ability to demand bodies are on the line, then we can really do something. Because I do believe we have the talent to still have a great season.

But there has to be a huge mindset change, there has to be a change of captain, there has to be a feeling of oneness on the pitch and a willingness to defend every gain line with total controlled ferocity.

If we can do that, because Radfords is able to instil that missing, never-say-die killer instinct into his team then we can quickly recreate our early optimism. But if he can't I would give him 10 matches, and if he cant rectify our quite pathetic mental strength that incredibly just cannot last for 80 mins. he'll be gone.

The Connor injury, scuppered Radders game plan against Cats. He was planning on only playing Kelly for an hour or so, because it was his first game and bring Carlos on when Kelly's legs tired. What with Ma'u only just returning from injury, and Fonua and Carlos still not 100%, our right edge did tire late in the game, and Tomkins took advantage of that. But those players will be better off for the game under their belts.

Well said. I think this is absolutely spot on.

How do you know what Lee's tactics were? (genuine question)

He is Lee

Because I listened to what he said in his after match interview.

For those bemoaning the disruption, we have had our first choice spine available for all games with the exception of Houghton v Leeds which, ironically, was our best performance. No excuses for our ongoing inability to unlock a defence

[list[/listWe're in second place for try assists. 1 less than leaders Wigan. So we must be unlocking them somewhere. And our top three players with assists are Connor, Sneyd and Kelly (3 in his one and only game)

Lee
Even you must see we are seriously poor in unlocking a defence in the opposition 20.
Maybe bring Purtill in as your assistant coach for some fresh ideas and let Last coach the reserves

First, let me say, I am on the fence, leaning to the change side re Radford.

However, to suggest we haven't had recent success, is just plain blind to the facts.

As has been said, what happens in the next 5/6 games will point the way to how successful this season will be.

Time for Last to make it on his own in the wide world of employment IMO. If Radford ever does go, it's equally important that last isn't retained.