I kind of agree here bud, but it seems a lot more people have a similar opinion.
Regarding yeamo its slighty fickle to say all would've been forgiven IF he had grounded that ball.
Imo everyone of them deserves credit for that performance.
Agree completely tickle took the wrong option, but taking into account briscoe was positioned completely wrongly for 1st try and berro giving away a penalty for grapple on smith ( done something similar against warrington I believe that ended in them scoring ) I find it bemusing we still single out certain players.

Other than Berrigan we don't have a better centre imo. People get things into their heads with certain players and keep going at them. Anything Yeaman does from a positive perspective is ignored if he makes one bad tackle. What about the 3/4 times in a game where he stops attacks and helps to save tries.

It's the same with Horne, a number of players have mentioned his one kick out on the full. Long did it early in the season in a match and it was not mentioned once. Sinfield also kicked out on the full, big deal.

How many Hull players missed tackles for the two McGuire tries and the disallowed Smith try, are those players being singled out.

That doesn't make him a good centre. It just highlights a big weakness in our backs.


This simply isn't true. My main problem with him is with his attacking game in any case.


How many of them bombed two tries? As the title of the thread indicates, he's being singled out for that rather than for his defence.

Yeaman is a solidly average player. His defence is not a weakness particularly but it also isn't as strong as some claim whenever he gets discussed. In attack he is usually dangerous on the end of a short pass near the line but has little else in his armoury. His backing up and general awareness is atrocious for a centre and his pace is borderline.

He'd be decent backup to a proper centre, but should never be first choice in a side hoping to challenge the top sides. His automatic selection despite his distinctly average form for the last four years is a puzzle and a concern, as was the very long contract he was given.

Berrigan played better in one single game than Yeaman has in four seasons.

We'll have to agree to disagree. I wish Yeaman had left and joined Saints or Leeds, then we would have seen his true potential rather than in a side where Manu gives him the ball once in a blue moon instead of trying to carry 10 players on his back to the try line. It was noticeable the two times Briscoe got good ball from Berrigan was when Berrigan got good ball from the poeple inside him.

I thought Berro looked sharp at centre on Saturday.

Yeaman had 2 great games against Wire this season. Matt King who is a very good centre never got a look in with him. His defence in those games was 1st class for me. It's all about opinions but to say that Berrigan played better in one game than Yeaman has in the last 4 years is a bit harsh imo.

Yeaman has got flaws in his game no doubt about it but I just think he's put in some good performances this year and gets some unnecessary criticism on here at times. Saying that he should have taken the Horne pass in the 1st Half.

There's no doubt that our outside backs have been starved of service over the last few years. I do think that this is used too readily to excuse Yeaman's lack of form though. Poor service shouldn't stop him backing up breaks or generally being alive to the few opportunities available.

It was noticeable the two times Yeaman got the ball in excellent scoring positions he dropped it. On the end of two flat passes - the kind of service he is supposed to thrive on but apparently never gets. He hasn't gone to the top of the game because he isn't one of the top centres in the game. His brief flirtation internationally was an over achievement.

Very good point, ive said this for a while that Manu gets a lot of the balls that Yeamo used to.

For me Yeamo had a decent season and has put Briscoe in for a few that he wouldnt have done for Raynor

Dont see how he can have so many critics after saturday

So how you explain his call to the England train on squad ?

I can't explain it - certainly not on form. Same for many of the train on squad. And last time I checked it was Steve McNamara who had to explain the selections in that squad not me.

I'll put a question to the floor - when was the last time Yeaman turned a game for us ? Got MOM ? Even Turner has managed that this year and he is a makeshift centre. Yeaman is an average SL player and precisely the type of player we need to improve on if we are to progress. His auto-selection in the team has done him no favours in my view.

He has taken plenty of those flat passes this season too. He needs to improve as do most players, he is by no means safe in his position if Berro starts to play centre and Briscoe gets a shot and does well but he is still a far better option for me than Whiting or Turner. Turner is a bit of a liability in the centres from a defensive pov.

That's my main problem with it. He does appear untouchable and an auto selection regardless of form. When on top form he is a good centre but I don't think he has been for a good while particularly with his attacking play. No player should have an automatic right to a place in the end it does them no favours whatsoever.