Is this the reason people hate for him? Jason smith did wrong, do we hate him, we all have family members/mates who have done wrong, do we hate them?

emotional when playing us, looked to me he just smirked and laughed at the fc fans, I don't hate him at all I have never met him I just don't want to see him back at our club if they do take him back im not going to protest or not go to games just would prefer our club to look at more loyal players like Yemo and such like for jobs within the club

Maybe he thought the section of fans was the ones who smashed his grans Windows & smashed his uncles Range Rover sport, or wished his child to get cancer, I don't think he was professional enough to override heckling, chants from fans, but I know everything that went on was in his head at the time, I called him a fat bar-steward when he was woohooing, but come end of the game, it was forgot about.

Personally? Nah, dont hate him. I dont really like him on as a person, but hey ho.
In my opinion, anyone who has admitted to half of the things he has done, regardless of the apologies years after, are a very easy person to dislike, or 'hate' if you will.
The amount of people who hate him is probably very small, most people just dont like him, but all seem to get banded into the frothing at the mouth pitchfork posse.

Getting the book for Christmas so need to read it before i make my mind up .

Let he who is with out sin cast the first stone as they say

don't agree with that sort of behaviour no one deservers that, but there is a way of doing things unfortunately he was given bad advise and I'm sure he regrets it now but he loved and milked it the time end of the matter for me and him at hull fc I hope

He insists that he never wanted to leave. He also states that he never left for money. Reading the book I would dispute both statements.

He went for the money pure and simple. He knew exactly what he was doing. He had 18 months of a 36 month unsigned contract to run. He was on £75k a year with us.
He claims that he would have earned £200k tax free from a testimonial year. On what basis he makes this claim is not apparent.
But if he had got all that then he would have had a further £310k in his pocket.
He went to Rovers for £110k per year for 42 months. He also got £80k in his pocket for signing for them. Hudgell also said he would pay his legal fees. Now do the maths. I would also like to know what he needed legal fees paying for. If the move was all above board then legal expenses wouldn't be required.

Now you can all make up your mind on that. But as per his book these are the facts. Naturally we haven't got Hull FC's side of the matter and I doubt we ever will. I know which way I am swaying on this matter.

Also in the book he tells about how the build up to the 2006 Grand Final was a farce. The reason being money. I believe this was not fully supported by the squad and certainly not by the coaching staff. Again make up your own mind. It was our biggest game of the season and possibly the biggest game in many players careers. What was he most concerned with?

Cooke wasted his talent. Much the same as my heroes from the 80s he was more interested in beer. Cut that out and he would potentially have made it internationally. He certainly wouldn't have had the brushes with the law. He possibly wouldn't have treated women so badly.

The club stood by him through all that cra9. The club gave him his chance. Yes the whole testimonial thing was possibly handled badly. Certainly his opinion of Heatherington is probably exactly the same as many of us. But his attempts to paint himself as some kind of victim in it all do not wash with me.

I will forever remember his try in Cardiff.
I will forever remember is part in the semi against Saints.
I will forever remember his role in 2006. But I won't forgive him his part in 2007 fiasco.

The club failed to replace him that's a fact. I will also add there a several players I'd claim were the biggest influences for us in the SL era. Smith, Swain, Horne and half of this years squad, before him.
But he was totally at fault for how 2007 ended. Big man faced his team mates and his bosses to say good bye. But he let them all down imho (but it wasn't for money )

As for other parts of the book. He reads a game brilliantly (or so he says). His analysis of plays is worth reading (Is it in retrospect or did he actually know all that while playing) . He will be a good coach. Would I have him in any leading role at Hull FC? I don't know. Certainly not head coach as things stand.

I wish him well. I am glad he has stopped drinking heavily and beating women. The world is a better place for that. But I don't buy his story.

I will have a pint 'Paul Cooke'. Period

Your prerogative to fund his next 'handy fists' venture.

There's NO EXCUSES. Scumbag.

Would be a great addition to our coaching team -IMO

Before in read his book I thought he was a . Now it's obvious at one stage in his life he certainly was. But did he screw hull FC ? No he didn't. We in the guise of Heterington and Rule screwed him. What a pair of muppets. They put FC back Fuve years or so. Took the cash abs off they went. Ruke shouldn't be allowed anywhere near our sport having read this. I note no ones sued Cooke over what he said so we can draw our own conclusions about who tells the truth.
It seems he's exorcised hid ghosts and totally turned his life around. Well done to him That would not have been easy.it seems in the rugby world he us well respected as an up and coming coach.
Can I forgive him for going to the dark side? Do I now understand why he did it? Yes. Should we try and get him to join FC coaching staff? I think so. He's been ere and done it all. He's obviously a deep thinker about the game. In some ways it's a pity it didn't come off when Pearson set it all in motion. By now it would all be water under the bridge and we'd have all moved on
One thing the book clearly shows is all the keyboard know alls knew fookall

don't hate the bloke never met him, I agree with Rendell on this one great post mate, swain summed it up for me when he refused to shake his hand, he let his mates down for money, it wasn't as though he was on a poor wage, but hey ho its gone now, I get a feeling from having read the book he has regrets about leaving hull, still a good read,

I don't profess to know what Cooke was earning at Hull, but on the basis he make the team tick, I can imagine if he was not in the top 3 earners, that would have caused an issue.

This is not a dig at you, just this thread in general, but there are a few self righteous folk on here. If any one of us was unhappy at work we would do something about it. Would you move jobs within the same city for a significant pay increase. Anyone who says not is either already loaded or lying.

If Cooke was unhappy at work, this could well have had an impact on his personal life. We know from at the time it was a turbulent path he was walking.

At the time he left Hull I was livid that the situation was allowed to have even got to that state. I'll hold my hands up and say I called him all the names under the sun when he lined up against us for rovers. Do I wish him personal misery (as it would appear a few on here would!), then absolutely not. The very fact that Hull FC never sought legal redress speaks volumes of the shoddy nature of the clubs management at the time. In a way I actually admire Cooke for the way he has carved out a coaching career from the ashes of what I'd imagine he would describe as a player career which never realised its potential.

For me Cooke has a very astute rugby brain. I for one would welcome him to Hull FC in a coaching capacity.

He tells you the wages he was on in the book. So no guess work there. It's only my opinion and after reading the book I think he let his club .supporters .and team mates down for a few Bob in his pocket. Imo reading between the lines he would have done it different given a chance. It's done now and people will have different views on it.

I thought we won a court case against him and were allowed to claim damages against him at any time in the following 5 years. I remember Rule saying there was no rush and we would bide our time.
Then it was no surprise that nowt happened !!

I don't personally hate him, but he certainly acted very poorly and let his team mates and the fans down. I just can't ever forgive him for that.

No; the RFL suspended him for 6 months/games, but Hull never took legal action, despite Rule's sabre rattling. I'd argue that this was not surprising. There was a statute of limitations (or time to let it all blow over) of several years.

Loved those arguments.