sharp wasnt the reason we lost but he massivly contributes to it, he works very hard but hes to unrealiable wether its defending or taking high bombs and hes to lightweight. when a high ball goes up to sharp who just know that hes likely to drop it

Not going to get into the his he e or isn't he debate, but what did supprised me was how he struggled to close Broughy down in the race to the try line. It was was also very noticable that he was totally on his own after the trys were scored with no words of encouragement from the rest of the team or the captain.

Those trying to use a poor performance from one of our genuine quality players to defend Sharp, who is has already been mentioned a Championship player at best need to give their heads a bang. Sharp is awful.

Both Wingers was shocking today but Sharp is a awful winger....got caught out of positon umpteen times and not just the 1st match either....our right hand side looks better with Whiting on the wing.

The thing with Sharp is, I actually now expect the opposition to score everytime they kick or run at him. He's completey ineffective in defence and just looks completely confused as to what to do.

The thing that concerns me and I am sure many a Hull fan is that our right side is continually targeted and yet we see no improvement when the chips are down. That is down to coaching and what happens on the training pitch. It is clearly not being addressed.

You can excuse dropped balls and the occassional lapse in defence etc, but when its done time and time again then the coaching has to be questioned.

Or the coach playing a winger who is out of his depth.....Craig Hall got dropped for a damn sight less.

Surely not.

whiting will be on the wing against rovers

He,d better be or Dobson will bomb Sharp all day.

To be fair and in hindsight Gleeson was also pretty gash today but that Sharp was still very poor

couple of times in defence gleeson should of pushed up instead of hanging back and in attack well he dint get a chance did he no suprise at all

I hope so. All of the backs without exception were poor today IMO. Picking out Sharp isn't really fair. Having said that for those who seem to worry that Briscoe doesn't get the same level of criticism that may be true, however there is a reason why Briscoe plays for England and Sharp doesn't - it's because he's a lot, lot better at playing on the wing than Sharp is.