Personally I doubt Hall will ever make it as a top centre, he has the ability but not sure he has the belief and the brain. If we retain him he will be useful cover who will do a good job and score the off cracking try, if he leaves then so be it, no harm done.

How often has Hall played at option 1, in his preferred postion for a sustained period of time?

How often has Whiting? And yet he performs consistently well.

However much you want to believe it, Hall is not a top SL centre. He'd be a great signing for a top 4 championship club, but he's been around long enough for anyone other than the most optimistic fan to realise that he's not cut out for this level of rugby. If we ever want to improve, we have to let [isome[/i players go and use their salaries for better players. We can't re-sign everyone and expect to magically become a better side. Out of the squad we currently have, Hall has to be one of the ones to make way.

Consistently well! Are you sure about that son,,,not always

I'm not saying he never does anything wrong, but his overall performances have, over the course of the season, been of a consistently high standard. Son.

Whiting and Hall are different characters. Not comparable one bit. Whiting can play 1-13 and will generally have a good game. Hall needs to be left centre or left wing and has never had a run there.

But Whiting hasn't had the preassure of knowing one mistake will cost him his place in the team for the next 5 games.

Hall could have being something great but we as a club ruined him, he did not ruin himself. All he needed was to bulk up a bit and sort out his defence and he had the potential to be a great centre, now I reckon he has lost the will to play the game.

In your ever-so-humble opinion, of course.

Good job he was on the pitch today though.

Be intresting to see what happens when calderwood is ready......for me Calderwood should be behind Whiting and Hall for the team.

I'd bring him back in, ATEOTD Whiting/Hall have done decent jobs but Calderwood is an out and out winger and we miss his pace and enthusiasm.

Aye, cos if whiting was on the wing were he started, he would have been in front of Tansey

Here we go, Hall scores a try and now he's been ruined by the club. With the usual suspects in full flow.

Hall isn't good enough on a consistant basis.

I agree....but it is not worth the argument any more...mind you that is class the club ruined him

That's the point entirely. Of course he's capable of doing good things, but he's not consistent enough to make it at this level.



Surely you don't believe this. He was promising as a youngster, but didn't progress as well as his early promise suggested he might. It happens. A lot.



Of course. Goes without saying!

Seems to happen to us more than other clubs...Lee and Thackry didnt do it either......How would you feel if you had 1 bad game and was dropped when others are as bad....Hall will always be a scapegoat.