Hall's constant looking for the intercept nearly cost us on several occasions. He's a liability in defence. I am alone in thinking that I'd prefer Whiting's common sense and all round game in the centre with Hall's pace out on the wing?

Have you ever seen a real centre play?

I don't mean a frustrated 2nd rower like Yeaman or Senior, I mean a real centre. Someone who has a turn of speed, is swift of foot, can come off either foot and is always looking to put either his winger away or turn the ball back infield.

what do you expect a centre to do?

I'm with baldy on this, Hall has gradually had his skills coached out of him

i have coddy, last one i saw like that was called jimmy leulaui

Name me 5 such players in SL now. The games moved on. Deal with it.

Funny how people forget them little points scored is crucial in a game played like tonites was,,if you doubters can do do any better please do

Sweet; I'll ring Agar tomorrow and get myself put intot he team to shore up that side of the defence!

you do that that but i dont think they need 4 foot circus piggy me midgets,,who knows feck all about nothing,and you can quote me on that!!

Always defended Hall, but he looked shocking tonight. Lets hope it ain't permanent

On the scoreboard it was Hall's goals that were the difference tonight.

Bit unfair IMO to single out Hall for criticism , as there were quiet a few others not performing , the ineptitude of Wakefield certainly helped matters.

The half back combination of Horne and Washbrook - although no where near your first choice - was anonymous.
If ever there was a game for the experienced Richard Horne to step up , this was it , but failed to do so IMO. Is it time to get rid of him too?

Hall wasn't as bad as Tansey.

Thought he had a dcent game, thought his defence was goo, make some good tackle and decisions in defence, handling was a concern though couple of balls he should have taken.

Jury still out for me if he stays next year.

If i recall correctly;Whiting (and his common sense)took the same options last night resulting in another set of 6 against us in our own half also took the wrong option when conceding the try but he doesn't get lambasted by anyone, would rather Hall take that option knowing that he will go the length of the field instead of someone who can't.

Don't think Hall was as bad as some are making out and i get the impression that he is getting picked out for the usually weekly kicking unnecessary and if your looking for someone who is inconsistent then look no further then Tansey.

Other than whiting, all of the backs were gash last night. Unfair to single out hall

Briscoe had another strong game.

If its the same incident im thinking of, he had to make a play for the ball. If it went to Wakey hands, they were certain to score as they had a 3/4 overlap. IMO Whiting going for the intercept was a very clever decision, as the only other option he had was to conceed a try.