Agreed, there's many more in front of him that need the boot!

Who can you say from that team deserve to go
i can only think of thorman, tickle and king

Reserve grade rugby is gash at the moment. I would not use form at that level as a guide to SL suitability.

But it's still out on the field where he could be targetted at and still has to make plenty of metres in attack and defence.

If it makes you feel happier. The standard of reserve grade is appalling at the moment. TBF i didn't think he did all that bad tnite but he is certainly no better than Maloney and IMO he should be shipped off home.

I do agree though, I have said in another thread that he doesn't look upto the standard unless he does get hell of alot fitter.

Totally agree, he is very ordinary, he may take a bit of stopping initially when he comes on, but becomes easier to handle and I don't think he'll be the tackle buster we need.

He needs to be released at the end of the season and we need to offer maloney a 2 year deal

I didn't think he was too bad when he was on. The error aside he ran hard and tackled well and thats all you can ask.

Every tackle he made was very hard, in the second half, look at the look peacock gives him after the hit he put on him, forced a mistake by ablett with his first tackle. He didnt look like he had tired at all, its just agar prefers to play safe with dowes. King didnt get much game time either!

I've not seen anything from him that makes me want him to stay at the club whether it been in the first team or the reserves, he's not good enough imo.

He was and is capable of playing 2 20 min spells according to those that have seen him in the reserves etc. Agar just continually makes inept calls.

He did alot more than King did who once again appears immune from criticism on here. I would go as far as saying i didnt even realise King was on the pitch.

same with moa though, he got absolutely no game time whatsoever for him to make an impression

Dowes will be burnt out by july/august at the rate agar keeps him on the pitch for

I think its big Hutch with his head shaved just as crap last night