Thought was very good

For what we have had to put with for the last few years he is a big improvement

Good but not great

Will look even better if we can put Horney to full back & a decent Stand Off in (easier said than done). Seymour tackles like a forward.

He was good tonight, but needs a better partner at halfback,than we currently have.

Neither am I. He's a decent player, but not top 4 material on what I've seen so far.

Especially when Hodgson scored his second try

Pushed Manu for MOM tonight, starting to settle in now IMO. With a quality half back partner and licence to roam on both sides of the pitch I think he'd blossom further as well.

I thought he had a good game for you guys today.

Benji Marshall and Jonathan Thurston rolled into one... Seriously he moves us around the park..he tackles above his size..he has a good kicking game..and he's staying fit and playing most weeks..Im happy so far..

I thought our kicking game was quite average tonight.

As is being said, he needs a better partner and then he might be. I don't think many sides in SL have 2 genuinely top drawer halves, personally. Only Catalan IMO.

Thought he had a very good game and showed we have good strength in that position now. Just need to strengthen in other areas. Some people expect too much from a single player. Tomkins, Thurston, Marshall and Slater are freaks and few and far between.

He's an organiser, who tackles anything can run the ball in and not fall apart in the tackle and can kick well. What are people expecting of him to have the flair of Shaun Johnson? I'm actually happy with him as our 7 and is the better of the two from out half backs. Another game were Horne gets the ball and slows the play down.

Yes, he might be. He might not though.