Agree it is all about differing opionions, however his results speak volumes for me arguable the best British coach available.

I agree on that point would only go for him if no one else available.

Oh without a doubt I would have a few of the Aussie coaches as 1st choice.

Would you sooner have Nobby above Agar?

My personal opinion is (will not be popular I know) but I would sooner have him with Agar.

Have him instead of Agar...What would you do with Webster?

He would still play a big part, I would possibly consider putting him in charge of Youth development, which in my opinion needs to improve at Hull we have a good set up though we are far behind the likes of Saints & Wigan.

For me the problem is they scout at 12/13 ish and concentrate on those players, even though players skills and development improve and change, we run an under 16s and won the Hull & District league last season, FC only watched us once.

Love him or hate him hes the best coach this country has,
did very well to throw that Crusaders team together in that time and finish 8th.

Spot on

I would bin Agar and keep Webster. Agar has proved that's he's simply not up to scratch.

Noble over Agar every time.

Without a doubt.

Noble could just be appointed as Director of Rugby, then Agar could be quietly phased out without anyone losing face.

If we were looking for a coach then I would snap him up.

get him on board now because we will win nothing with agar still cannot believe the board gave him a 2 year contract, you could write down on the back of a stamp what agar knows about rugby league noble has been their done it and worn the t shirt. I,m sure agar would be snapped up by a nl1 club

Well Agar took us from 11th to 6th (cats hair from 4th), recruited well, but don't let that get in your way.

and he still couldnt get a decent performance out of us!!