Decision as in permanent or for the rest of the season?

I'm not against either for the rest of the year. Still question around defence on both of them, maybe it's a trust thing and not knowing the system.

Just loans for rest of season, they cannot play for there parent clubs after Sunday if they play next week for Hull

Both need big games tomorrow.

If not and with players coming back and our own young kids i don't see the point in keeping them.

Unless they have signed for next season, then might aswell keep them.

Can't see wire and Saints being desperate for them this season.

I don't have full confidence in all of Hodgson's abilities, but I think he's probably qualified to identify which player is the better fullback. If you play anywhere in the spine for Hull, it's matter of time before you're the scapegoat and I think Jamie's had his turn. I think fans have probably been over critical of his performances, which have by and large have been similar to those around him. That said, I think most coaches in the league would choose Walker above Shaul.

Shaul to Wakey on Loan confirmed by the Club.

Shame to see his FC career end the way it has, been a great servant and we will always be grateful for the final winning try back in 2016.

However, it doesn't sound like he has covered himself in glory in recent weeks. It should be a reminder that nobody is bigger than the club itself and one positive I can give to Hodgson is that he is certainly letting players who were previously pretty cosy are aware of that.

Not sure this is the end, can t see him leaving with him due a testimonial.

Think he can sign permanently next season IF wakey stay up.

Would still be due a testimonial if that happened apparently

Walker can't even get in an average leeds side so doubt it

He'll have a testimonial anyway I would think

10 years next year

Yes he can, but think he would earn more money if at Hull, if he wasn't a Hull player, a few of our fans maybe wouldn't attend his events.

Thats not true now is it? Walker was the No.1 FB at Leeds up until his injury against Huddersfield in April, since his injury they resigned Hardaker and Walker has only just returned from injury and needs games, we needed some pace and bodies so it made sense to sign him on loan and there is obviously some issue with Shaul or he wouldn't be getting shipped out.

Shaul has been a great servant to the club but he just hasn't looked the player he was even since his injury, whether some of it is also down to having a new coach instead of Radford who knows but sadly its seems best for both parties to part ways. Its a sad way for Shauls time at Hull to come to an end but that's sport in some ways.

Is that the average Leeds side that scored 11 tries against Shaul?

Shaul did well then if it was 13 against 1

And if he refused to move and just decided to sit out the year?

That could stop the club signing a player they need?

Can’t see too many fans supporting his testimonial in that scenario?