Please be more constructive/specific. You saying Moa hasn't shown promise OR that we haven't made individuals scapegoats?

Both showed why they should be included in the 17.

Got to agree, Whiting HAS to be in the starting 13 for us. He has a proper rugby league brain, great positioning and his passing, as already mentioned, was first class. Why he was dropped the other week is beyond me!

Sam Moa gave us something that we have lacked for most of the season with his go forward, was very impressed with him tonight.

Now all we need to do next week at Cas is start from the first whistle!!

Does anyone know how many minutes Moa played?

Primarily that Moa has never been blamed for a loss, and more generally that the entire squad has been blamed for our pi$$ poor season. And the coach. And the board. And the stadium cat.

While I agree that individual players are occasionally unfairly criticised/blamed following losses, it's generally a minority sport and has not been particularly in evidence this season IMO.

The coach picks the team

The coach makes the interchanges

Moa showed that he can do more than 10mins, just shows that Agar hasn't used him properly all season

I felt he showed far more enthusiasm than most of the pack has done all season

Whiting should never have been dropped for G.Horne in the first place. Moa has just proved what most of us have been saying for the last few months, he is more than capable of playing longer than 10 minutes a game.

DRopping whiting was a disgraceful decision. Problem I can see is g horne will probably get a contract extension

I disagreed with you (or someone) when they said he should be tried at fullback, so I'll have a large slice of humble pie. I've always rated Whiting very highly, however, and I can't see why anyone would say he's not good enough to be in the 17 every single week when fit. Like someone said earlier, it doesn't matter where he's playing - just make sure he's there somewhere.

Moa ran like a prop should run tonight. It was the most refreshing of refreshing changes.

Sounds harsh but I really hope he doesn't. We have far better options for any of the positions he can play.

More than 15, came on after about 25 minutes and was still there just after half time, had a breather then came back.....i think!!

A good game from Sam tonight.

Moa had a great game tonight; he get's us on the front foot when he drives it in which we have been missing all season

A few more performances like this and he may be offered a contract for next season ? im confused with the quota system lol

For the experience the lad has i have been impressed with Moa every game he has played. I have said before why the kid hasn't been given more game time in a pack that has generally struggled all year is beyond me.

Likewise Whiting....why he isn't in the side (starting) every week is another baffling situation. Here we have arguably our only player with a geniune RL brain yet he is often left on the sidelines.

Agar hasn't a clue and only appears to stumble across these selections due to injuries!