The common denominator with Aussie coaches is...............they ALL have a good scrum half to work with.

Would they all get on though??

Our scrum half will do us a job with the right tactics. He is capable of passing the ball left or right he just doesnt do it. Thats all i'd want him to do, hit the centres in space.

He had a golden opportunity to do just that last night and instead he passed it to (or should I say just behind) the dummy runner. He's crap and needs to go.

He's not great but he doesnt deserve the stick he gets on here for me. He plays to the tactics he is given and the set up we play to.

The one thing I thought when we signed him was "at least our kicking game will be half decent."

I was wrong. The one thing most people thought he could do, he's not doing.

Our tactics don't help him, but there's no escaping the conclusion that he's a very poor player.

He's underperforming in a side that is hugely under performing. Disagree thats he's very poor but like you im disappointed with his options and his kicking game. He isnt the main problem that we have though.

He's one of them. I agree that certain fundamental flaws in the team don't help him, but there's a reason Hudds moved him from half back and then got rid altogether.

(Hint: It's because he's sh[ii[/it.)

We'll agree to disagree. He aint the best but he's far from sh*t imo

Classic !!!!!

Ok. Agree to disagree. Again.

[size=50I still maintain if he was any more sh[ii[/it, he'd be brown and have bits of sweetcorn in him.[/size