Both are better than anyone you currently have at your club in there positions.

I know people will probably criticise him as a player now he's signed for rovers, but I'd have loved Mcillorum for a year, despite his age he's still one of the best hookers in super league, he'd have been great for Balmforth and Borough to learn off too, he's as tough as they come and a great competitor, would give our side a bit of grunt which we lack a bit too. Wonder how many bans him and JWH pick up between them

Not at their age, Mcilorum offers zero threat, strong defender that's it.

I'd be disappointed with either for next season.

Mcillorum is as cooked as Houghton is

Do Rovers have an academy?

Naiqama looks it too

Just signed a young hooker from London too, the amount of young players Peters has signed, not given a chance and moved them on.

It's a reflection of the market that Saints have gone in for him.

You can question some of the signings we have made but we have given a number of academy players an opportunity and most of them look more than capable.

Tindall back out on loan to Bradford again, we owe the Bulls owner a nice Xmas present after taking in all these waifs and strays

Previously championship young player of the year, probably another good signing for them

Can you honestly say that you'd have given all of those academy lads an opportunity if your signings this season hadn't been so garbage?
It's great that there getting games, but it's more out of necessity isn't it?

Might go as well as Greg Richards, Cory Hall, Reiss Butterworth, AJ Wallace, Louis Senior.

Rovers have got a good squad, but they do make odd signings

Not all but the fact we could have played Pele or Ockunbor, Moy in front of Moy etc, shows the direction we ate trying.

If Hull had signed these all the people praising them would find the negatives.

If we had signed him, certain posters would comment would be that he has never played SL and would be coming back from nearly a year out after a serious injury.