Just been on the Red Devils fans forum. Most seem to think he's a solid signing. A lot questioning the 3 yr deal though. All fair points.

Looking at Twitter you would think they had signed Nathan Cleary.

Id say on recent form he is a poor signing, if he can replicate his firm from 16/17 then he would be a good signing, won't have that pack he had at Hull to work with though.

Not me I've been on here a few times in the last few years saying how average Sneyd was and you were getting our then fourth choice halfback as your main man, that never went down too well.

As it's stands now I think we are getting a guy who to be fair probably has the best kicking game in the comp who other than that offers little with ball in hand, just hope he does the kicking well and Brodie Croft runs the show.

As a side if the choice was Sneyd or wiggy from Leeds then thanks Hull.

Gale if fit is better than Sneyd, Gale had a good season in 2020, Sneyd hasn't played well consistently since 2017. We have had his best years when he played with our outstanding pack in those cup years wins, but without that type of pack he is average.

His kicking isn't as good as people think either, was poor last year, he will set up some trys with kicks, but that's because that was our only option in many games.

I'm not going to argue who's the best because I think there both pretty average, but I think you'll be holding your breath when your half backs get tackled as both are made from digestives, we'll see what happens.

If it happens then we have two young lads to fill it, which will be a great long term benefit.

Advantage of investing in am academy I suppose.

Agree with you about his kicking. A lot of the trys he set up with kicks when attacking the opponents line I feel was more to do with how good Connor is in the air. I appreciate Sneyd has to put the kick in the right spot to begin with, and he was good at that, but any half in the league worth their pay cheque should be able to do that from close range. Sneyd's kicks wouldn't be half as effective if it wasn't Connor they were going to. Even Swift is very good in the air for a smaller guy.

Who are the two young lads to fill it and please don't say macnamara and hookam

Sneyds kicking out of hand was awful, 90 percent of the time going straight to the fullback, always seemed to be Connor who got the 40/20s or put more effective kicks in

I'm sure he didn't mean those 2. I think he meant McNamara and Hookem

Well that's ok then