Yeppp. Apologies to him at the minute, playing well. But, it's early days.

In the interest of fairness I too will give him credit for the way he has played in the last 2 games. In fact he looks completely unrecognisable from the player at Cas for the last 3/4 years both in his attitude and ability. I think Gentle deserves some of the credit for that as well.

Agree, he's impressed me in his games so far, not quite at the stage of saying we need to keep him next season, quota/cap issues would need to be considered, but I am happy to say that, so far, he's proven my initial reaction wrong.

Fresh start and he's proving all the doubters wrong so far (me included). Another solid game yesterday, and he also had the tag of penalty machine, don't know what his stats are but dosen't seem to have given away many.

Was planning to retire and head down under at end of season, but any offer from Hull and I think he will do another season, I'm warming to the idea....

Playing well the lad is hasn't had a bad game for us yet.

I'm just thankful he didn't turn out this bad ....

rlhttp://forums.rlfans.com/viewtopic.php?f

Whilst I'm willing to admit he's played better than expected, I stand by my 'cheap-shot merchant' comment. The high shot in the derby was a typical example IMO, nasty and you could see it coming as soon as he went towards the player. Whether he was wearing black and amber or black and white, that's not the kind of thing I like to see.

Stop being gay, its rugby league and players from opposition sides have been doing it for years to us whilst we be all nicey nicey. It sgood to see someone who riles the oppo sides as we havent really had one since Hepi

i would be happy to see him in a fc shirt next season, been one of our best since he arrived. hes either playing for a contract or putting himself in the shop window, either way keep it up goldie !!!!!!

We've missed some agression in recents weeks, McGoldrick brings us that but his overall game so far has been much better than I was expecting.

who mentioned going into raptures?
giving new players a fair chance would suffice.Isn,t your opening line a contradiction?

I said this when we signed him. We've missed having a bit of menacing presence on the field since Ogre has been out.

McGoldrick has provided a great spark in our attack and gives us extra dimension in the 20 metre zone. We've been missing that.

On the evidence so far, I'd have no problem with giving him a 12 month deal if he'll take it.

It wasn't nasty whatsosver imo, just a high tackle.

It's not just menace though is it. Like Whiting, a genuine ball handler, something we have badly lacked.

And the guy seems to be really enjoying his rugby now.