I understand that and I rate him very highly, but for me there is a bit too much mongrel in him and he is a dirty ..

Finch for me, closely followed by Tomkins

FC players in with a shout imo...Lynch, Houghton.

Three months later has anyone new stood out ?
Westwood , ratchford ,tomkins and finch top 4 for m.o.s

Hardaker , wakins or charnly for young player of the year

Tompkin by far, there isn't a player in the league anyway as good as him.

Just look at his stats,

29 trys (2nd)
29 trys assist (2nd)
35 Clean breaks (1st)
146 tackle busts (1st)

McIlorum, by a mile.

Ganson most obvious mistakes of year.

Child what the F**k am I doing here

Has to be Tomkin I reckon

Tomkins gets my vote.

Hope Potter gets coach of the year, he has done a massive job keeping the Bradford players motivated through months of off-field drama.

Tomkins or Westwood.

Ben Westwood

Sam Tomkins

James Roby

For those suggesting Lynch, by his standards he has had a below par season. At Bradford he would into double figures tries wise and would be a consistent off loader. Something he hasn't done at Hull.

I think some are getting carried away with Lynch as he has managed to avoid significant injury and has featured in most games. He plays a very similar role to what Ewan Dowes did a few seasons ago. A solid 80 minute player who doesn't let you down.

Quote Mild mannered Janitor="Mild mannered Janitor"Ben Westwood Sam Tomkins James Roby For those suggesting Lynch, by his standards he has had a below par season. At Bradford he would into double figures tries wise and would be a consistent off loader. Something he hasn't done at Hull. I think some are getting carried away with Lynch as he has managed to avoid significant injury and has featured in most games. He plays a very similar role to what Ewan Dowes did a few seasons ago. A solid 80 minute player who doesn't let you down.'" Apart from the trys Totally disagree, for a start he has has made 44 offloads and is 8th in the league in offloads, more than any other prop. Miles better than Dowes, makes more metres and better defender, not suggesting he should be MOS, but you are really playing down how good a prop his is. superleague.co.uk/player/67

Quote Mild mannered Janitor="Mild mannered Janitor"Ben Westwood Sam Tomkins James Roby For those suggesting Lynch, by his standards he has had a below par season. At Bradford he would into double figures tries wise and would be a consistent off loader. Something he hasn't done at Hull. I think some are getting carried away with Lynch as he has managed to avoid significant injury and has featured in most games. He plays a very similar role to what Ewan Dowes did a few seasons ago. A solid 80 minute player who doesn't let you down.'" Apart from the trys Totally disagree, for a start he has has made 44 offloads and is 8th in the league in offloads, more than any other prop. Miles better than Dowes, makes more metres and better defender, not suggesting he should be MOS, but you are really playing down how good a prop his is. superleague.co.uk/player/67

Remi Casty or Ben Westwood

Westwood will win it. Followed by
Tomkins
Hodgson (Brett)