I'm more bothered about his age and injury record than how he's played the last couple of weeks. I'd guess he's costing a lot more than phelps

have to agree

He's had two poor games but do do plenty of player's. Only worry are his hamstrings.

Ability wise he should do very well in SL.

agree but at leaste we should have some cover

Go and express your views on McKinnon on the Wests forum, and they'll label you a very deluded person. Obviously you'll know much more than the people that watch him week in, week out though.

yet phelps,s injury record doesn't concern you,why's that

I have watched this guy for quite a while and his last two games have been poor but prior to that he looked very good. Speed power good hands and an ability to back up I reckon he will go good but as usual some on here love to to diss players before they even pull the shirt on.

Well you said he was a waste of a quota spot. Who would you rather have as our full back?

Thread drift. This is about Mckinnon . Defensivley , He looks shocking.

The same fans who moaned like hell when the announcement was made that he was leaving? The same fans who had him second to Benji in the player of the season points?

He has had two bad games in the last two weeks, before that he was playing very well.

When did McKinnon become poor in defence?

same people who said fitzy was over the hill and o meley was a has been........