Would you have Noble if Wigan sack him?????????????

Yes

Over what we have now, yes I would.

Personally yes I would take Noble

No no no

No.....Can't stand the bloke.......and to be frank......He hates Hull!!!

Just look at his GB team selections of the past...He really did struggle to accomodate FC players even when they were head and shoulders above his own 'old faithfuls'. He ain't that good and was lucky to have had a great team at the Bulls, even though they all looked like steroid induced freaks Besides......we'd go over the cap just paying for his chewing gum!!!!!!!!!

I just think he has a lot more experience and knowledge than Agar..He is a firm coach (no player power with him).

I do not think it matter who we percieves he likes or does not..If he gets sacked he will have to work damn hard to regain his reputation so we would get the best out of him.

I would be surprised if he soes get the sack though

TBH if we lose on Friday and get beat on Sky next Saturday at Salford (not unlikely) then I can see the calls for Agars head getting far louder and we may well have another Kear/Sharp situation. IF Agar got the sack we all know that J.Sharp would simply take over, at least until the end of the season, which IMO wont change a thing. I'm not a fan of sacking coaches so I'd at least like to give Agar until the end of the season and if things aren't improving start sounding the right people out to take over.

The only person the club will ever replace Agar with is already sat next to him.
What if the club sound out a fresh coach who then says im not working along side another coach, I coach on my own. Hull wont pay Agar and Sharpy off. No chance !

Think we all know sharpe is to slide into Agars spot just when and at what time of the season this happens ??????????

Very probably true.

On the question of Noble, how many cries of despair would there be because we brought a "failed" or "has-been" coach in? There's talk about bringing Millward into Bradford. Is that the type of person we want here? A hero at Saints but an "ego-driven, foul-mouthed, garrulous genius" according to rlhttps://timesonline.typepad.com/rugby_league/2009/04/exclusive-the-d.html#commentsrl (hope that link works)

I would not have Sharp coaching at U-8's. He is a poor coach and a massive mistake by Hull to have him anywhere near the first team.

I agree Gordon, Lovely bloke but not my choice.
The only problem as I have said is the club will now have to pay both of them off which is gonna be expensive and just wont happen.

Another fine mess the board gets us into !!!