Neither, one was never much use and the other has no loyalty. I'd rather the club folded than have either back.

What a stupid statement to make.

I would take Cooke back in a coaching capacity.

It's an OPINION, people have them, just self righteous folk like you don't value anything but their own.

Seriously?? You would rather see the club go under than see someone come back. I've got to doubt your support for the club if that's your opinion.

Not when it's as moronic as yours.

None of the three are likely, which was the point I was (in hindsight, poorly) making

Id rather take Rule back than Judus - Rule was just a marketing man promoted beyond his ability - Judus is just that, a judus and should never be allowed near the club again

Well balanced viewpoint as ever

Wasn't he with the Hetheringtons daughter?

So, you'd rather have someone who was promoted to incompetence over someone with talent? You call a former player Judas yet you are the one who openly turns his back on the team if they are in a run of poor form.

Backs up my opinion that I'd rather have Cooke over Rule.

Were not all loaded accountant types like yourself so yeah when the rugby was dire, the team a joke and the club generally taking the p155 out of the fans then yeah i did decide to hardly attend as its was costing over £1-150 to take me mrs and the kids with food and drinks to basically watch dross. I was still a fan just couldnt support what was going on similar to how city fans are boycotting games because of the Allams

Well in Rule's day it was £20 or so to get in on the gate so £40 for you and your good lady. How many children do you have for the bill to reach £150? Don't really get why you'd include the cost of food, surely you have to eat regardless of whether you go to a game?

There will be no response to this as its about as bang on the money (no pun intended) as you can get.

Its the second time someone (earlier in the thread) has referenced the profession I ( as well as a few others on here) am in. I don't see the relevance of it. I am aware of many from all walks of working life who are ardent supporters of the club. I don't expect every follower of the club to attend every game as circumstances are different for all, but I find it difficult to take seriously criticism of the team, coach or the club from someone who actively says that they wont attend unless we are winning (and even then its touch and go).

Back on topic,

With Kelly out of the frame for the Salford game, I'd consider Cooke for a comback at 6 at the moment [sizeclearly this is a urine extraction[/size