I think it works the other way as well. Last night we watched the DVD of Leeds v Hull at Headingley in 2006. Because I have quite a few DVDs of the 2005 and 2006 season, particularly games in which Shayne McMenemy made a really telling contribution, he's becoming more of a legend each year in my eyes. Confused as to whether he was really a journeyman backrower with a decent boot on him, or whether seeing him score 2 in the semi at the Galpharm and force the error that led to us winning the cup umpteen times means he's an All Time FC Great.

How has it skewed my memory? He had one game there, and it was awful. He had other poor displays, just that one still stands out

Anyone remember a fat useless prop forward called dave brown who came across in the late 80's? Hardly played and was sent home early because he was garbage and lazy. We did sign some rubbish in the late 80's and early 90's

He didnt have a bad game - I remember this game and he scored a try that should of been given, he placed the ball down in front of the hull fans then Wellens came across and booted it away and we got a drop out IIRC!

Didn't he make his debut at the old Caravan Park?

What a bag-o-e.

Nobody remember Peter Spring?

Can we include Ryan Benjafield somewhere, or is actually playing a 1st team game a requirement?

Patrick Solal

agreed, complete cakka malla

He was alright as i remember

For me it has to be Hitro Okesene, if looks alone made you devastating he was the man, sadly he was utter e!

English wasn't he?

He was a Aussie international as well and had great reviews.......dont what as,as it was a rugby player....bleeding useless and the worst i have seen and that includes the walsh mob.