i like manu, fantastic player, but this year seems to be struggling in some games from the off, maybe hes carrying an injury?

Sika seemed to really struggle with the pace of the game today at times

Let's stay away from the personal abuse and name calling yeah? Karen.

He did say some games, not all year. And I agree with him tbf, he has lacked the consistency of last year. On his day he is a superb player, but he has had a few quiet ones. I think injury has played a part in that though.

miloudi was good today. I'd try him at centre and stick logan back on the wing

Not a bad shout - Miloudi has to play at the moment, if nothing else than to see what he's got.

Yes I could go for that.

Or perhaps put him at 6, Connor at centre and Logan on the wing.

I don't think him and kelly would work at half back

Maybe both a bit too "maverick" I suppose. In Sneyd's absence I think possibly the best replacement in terms of style is Harris. Connor has had some really good games in the halves but I think he is better suited to centre.

show me a superleague player who isn't carrying some sort of injury at this stage of the season

Sika was good last year but very not so in his first year here. He'll be going home

Mini is looking good again though

I'm not sure about Mini, a bit loose with the ball and misses a fair few tackles, strong running game though, I think one more season might be one too many. I suppose it all depends on if we can replace him and what Manu does

see your stalking again tinkerman, careful with your language is there really any need for it?

I've always been one of his bigger critics on here for the things you mention but I think he has been really good for the last month. If he keeps up that form and feels he has another year in him then I would be fine with that.

how he plays a full 80 min boy he must be fit, mixed bag this year but imo if he stays fit and continues like he has the last couple of matches hes worth another year, its not as though theres a lot of top second rowers about,